Accident and agency: a mixed methods study contrasting luck and interactivity in problem solving
Authors:
- 30 August 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Thinking & Reasoning
- Vol. 28 (4) , 487-528
Abstract
Problem solving in a materially rich environment requires interacting with chance. Sixty-four participants were invited to solve 5-letter anagrams presented as movable tiles in conditions that either allowed the participants to move the tiles as they wished or only allowed random shuffling (without rearranging the tiles post shuffling) thus contrasting pure luck with an interactive model. We hypothesised that shuffling would break unhelpful mental sets and introduce beneficial unplanned problem-solving trajectories. However, participants performed significantly worse when shuffling, which suggests luck plays less of a role than has been previously suggested. Granular analysis of seven critical cases revealed arbitrary path dependency across both conditions and moments of missed luck. It also questions current models of non-agentic luck and the ability to separate agent and luck. This research has implications for fostering better problem solving in an uncertain and fluid world.Keywords
This publication has 66 references indexed in Scilit:
- Insight versus analysis: Evidence for diverse methods in problem solvingJournal of Cognitive Psychology, 2013
- Random effects structure for confirmatory hypothesis testing: Keep it maximalJournal of Memory and Language, 2013
- Insight Problem Solving: A Critical Examination of the Possibility of Formal TheoryThe Journal of Problem Solving, 2012
- Type and token bigram frequencies for two-through nine-letter words and the prediction of anagram difficultyBehavior Research Methods, 2011
- Putting the ‘theory’ back into grounded theory: guidelines for grounded theory studies in information systemsInformation Systems Journal, 2010
- Insightful thinking2009
- Does Luck Exclude Control?Australasian Journal of Philosophy, 2009
- The origins of insight in resting-state brain activityNeuropsychologia, 2008
- Normative data for 144 compound remote associate problemsBehavior Research Methods, Instruments, & Computers, 2003
- Dynamics and constraints in insight problem solving.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 2002