Coarse taxonomy (tolerance-value averaging) biases Hilsenhoff’s family-level biotic index
Authors:
- 4 July 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Environmental Monitoring and Assessment
- Vol. 190 (8) , 446
Abstract
Hilsenhoff’s family-level index (FBI) combines information about the relative abundances of taxa and their tolerances to pollution. Versions of this index are used extensively in North America to assess water quality. When faced with constraints on time, money, or expertise, bioassessment practitioners have been tempted to calculate a version of the FBI with very coarse (e.g., order-level) taxonomy. Such an approach requires a degree of within-taxon averaging of tolerance values and raises questions about the degree to which accuracy is compromised and bias is introduced. Data from thousands of streams in Ontario (Canada) demonstrated that such tolerance-value averaging produces index scores and associated water-quality classifications that are not equivalent to those calculated with the standard family-level taxonomic precision. Two methods were used in an attempt to correct the order-level FBI scores to equivalence with the family-level index: (1) tolerance scores for the orders included in the calculation were calculated as abundance-weighted means of the scores of their component families, and (2) order-level FBI scores were estimated as predicted values from a polynomial regression of the two versions of the index. The use of abundance-weighted mean tolerance scores greatly improved the accuracy of the order-level index, and the regression-based correction reduced bias by equalizing the distribution of errors across the range of observed FBI values. Nonetheless, equivalence of scores was not demonstrated, and water quality was misclassified in 12 to 80% of cases. Practitioners are discouraged from the practice of tolerance-value averaging and are advised to adhere to the standard family-level FBI.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Tolerance values of benthic macroinvertebrates for stream biomonitoring: assessment of assumptions underlying scoring systems worldwideEnvironmental Monitoring and Assessment, 2013
- Taxonomic sufficiency: The influence of taxonomic resolution on freshwater bioassessments using benthic macroinvertebratesEnvironmental Reviews, 2008
- A regression-based equivalence test for model validation: shifting the burden of proofTree Physiology, 2005
- Evaluating Subsampling Approaches and Macroinvertebrate Taxonomic Resolution for Wetland BioassessmentJournal of the North American Benthological Society, 2002
- After site selection and before data analysis: sampling, sorting, and laboratory procedures used in stream benthic macroinvertebrate monitoring programs by USA state agenciesJournal of the North American Benthological Society, 2001
- Taxonomic resolution of benthic macroinvertebrate communities in bioassessmentsJournal of the North American Benthological Society, 2001
- Designing a Spatially Balanced, Randomized Site Selection Process for Regional Stream Surveys: The EMAP Mid-Atlantic Pilot StudyEnvironmental Monitoring and Assessment, 2000
- Implementation of a National Monitoring ProgramJournal of Environmental Management, 1994
- Rapid Field Assessment of Organic Pollution with a Family-Level Biotic IndexJournal of the North American Benthological Society, 1988