Comparing Accuracy and Biases of DNA Metabarcoding, Hybridization Capture, and Metagenomic Sequencing for Quantifying Herbivore Diets
Open Access
- 16 July 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Molecular Ecology Resources
- Vol. 26 (5) , e70175
Abstract
DNA metabarcoding using relative read abundance (RRA) is commonly applied to estimate herbivore diet composition, yet its quantitative accuracy remains uncertain. We assessed taxonomic resolution and quantitative performance of RRA from DNA metabarcoding compared to metagenomic sequencing and hybridization capture, using deer scats from feeding trials and recreated diet samples using plant tissues. All methods recovered plant composition in recreated diets ( R 2 = 0.59–0.82), indicating accurate scaling with biomass in the absence of digestion, with only minor bias from amplicon length in DNA metabarcoding. In contrast, RRA from scat samples performed poorly ( R 2 < 0.01) across all methods largely due to differential plant digestibility. Correcting for digestibility, measured with acid detergent lignin and acid‐insoluble ash, was strongly supported in mixed‐effects models and improved prediction of dietary composition, although species‐level variation remained. For metagenomic sequencing and hybridization capture, we also evaluated Relative Genome Coverage (RGC), a novel relative abundance metric quantifying the proportion of each plant's chloroplast genome covered by mapped reads, normalized for genome length. RGC further improved correlations in recreated diets ( R 2 = 0.82–0.84) and, with hybridization capture, largely overcame digestibility‐related biases in scat samples ( R 2 = 0.57) without correction. When such corrections are infeasible, hybridization capture with uncorrected RGC may achieve higher quantitative accuracy in scat samples. Our results provide practical guidance for improving molecular herbivore diet analysis and highlight the importance of accounting for digestion‐related biases.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institute of Food and Agriculture (WNP00848)
- National Science Foundation (2317537)
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluating the Quantitative Accuracy and Application of DNA Metabarcoding for Dietary Reconstruction in RuminantsEcology and Evolution, 2026
- Monitoring terrestrial wildlife by combining hybridization capture and metabarcoding data from waterhole environmental DNABiological Conservation, 2023
- Sequential detergent fiber assay results used for nutritional ecology research: Evidence of bias since 2012Wildlife Society Bulletin, 2022
- Comparing whole‐genome shotgun sequencing and DNA metabarcoding approaches for species identification and quantification of pollen species mixturesEcology and Evolution, 2021
- eDNA metabarcoding reveals dietary niche overlap among herbivores in an Indian wildlife sanctuaryEnvironmental DNA, 2020
- Minimap2: pairwise alignment for nucleotide sequencesBioinformatics, 2018
- PEAR: a fast and accurate Illumina Paired-End reAd mergeRBioinformatics, 2013
- BEDTools: a flexible suite of utilities for comparing genomic featuresBioinformatics, 2010
- Target-enrichment strategies for next-generation sequencingNature Methods, 2010
- Fast and accurate short read alignment with Burrows–Wheeler transformBioinformatics, 2009