Performance Evaluation of GNSS Position Augmentation Methods for Autonomous Vehicles in Urban Environments
Open Access
Abstract
Global Navigation Satellite Systems provide autonomous vehicles with precise position information through the process of position augmentation. This paper presents a series of performance tests aimed to compare the position accuracy of augmentation techniques such as classical Differential Global Navigation Satellite System, Real-time Kinematic and Real-time eXtended. The aim is to understand the limitations and choose the best position augmentation technique in order to obtain accurate, trustworthy position estimates of a vehicle in urban environments. The tests are performed in and around the German cities of Wuppertal and Duesseldorf, using a vehicle fitted with the navigation system POS-LV 220, developed by Applanix Corporation. In order to evaluate the real-time performance of position augmentation techniques in a highly challenging environment, a total of four test regions are selected. The four test regions are characterized mainly by uneven terrain with tall buildings around the University of Wuppertal, flat terrain with roads of varying width in the city centre of Wuppertal and Duesseldorf and flat terrain in a tunnel section located in the city of Wuppertal. The performances of the different position augmentation are compared using a Root Mean Square (RMS) error estimate obtained as an output from the Applanix system. Furthermore, a High-Definition map of the environment is used for the purpose of model validation, which justifies the use of RMS error estimate as an evaluation metric for the performance analysis tests. According to the performance tests carried out as per the conditions specified in this paper, the Real-time eXtended (RTX) position augmentation method enables to obtain a more robust position information of the vehicle than Real-time Kinematic (RTK) method, with a typical accuracy of a few centimeter in an urban environment.Keywords
Funding Information
- Aptiv Services Deutschland GmbH
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Satellite‐Based Augmentation Systems (SBASs)2020
- Performance analysis of real-time and post-mission kinematic precise point positioning in marine environmentsGeodesy and Geodynamics, 2020
- Range-Doppler Registration2020
- A Survey of the State-of-the-Art Localization Techniques and Their Potentials for Autonomous Vehicle ApplicationsIEEE Internet of Things Journal, 2018
- Implementation and Operational Use of Ground-Based Augmentation Systems (GBASs)—A Component of the Future Air Traffic Management SystemProceedings of the IEEE, 2008
- Evolution of the Global Navigation SatelliteSystem (GNSS)Proceedings of the IEEE, 2008
- The global positioning systemIEEE Transactions on Microwave Theory and Techniques, 2002
- Wide area augmentation of the Global Positioning SystemProceedings of the IEEE, 1996
- The Global Positioning System: Signals, measurements, and performanceInternational Journal of Wireless Information Networks, 1994
- NAVSTAR: Global positioning system—Ten years laterProceedings of the IEEE, 1983