A third verdict option: Exploring the impact of the not proven verdict on mock juror decision making.
Authors:
- Lorraine HopeLHLorraine Hope
- Edith GreeneEGEdith Greene
- Amina MemonAMAmina Memon
- Melanie GaviskMGMelanie Gavisk
- Kate HoustonKHKate Houston
- 1 June 2008
- journal article
- Published by American Psychological Association (APA) in Law and Human Behavior
- Vol. 32 (3) , 241-252
Abstract
In most adversarial systems, jurors in criminal cases consider the binary verdict alternatives of "Guilty" and "Not guilty." However, in some circumstances and jurisdictions, a third verdict option is available: Not Proven. The Not Proven verdict essentially reflects the view that the defendant is indeed culpable, but that the prosecution has not proven its case beyond a reasonable doubt. Like a Not Guilty verdict, the Not Proven verdict results in an acquittal. The main aim of the two studies reported here was to determine how, and under what circumstances, jurors opt to use the Not Proven verdict across different case types and when the strength of the evidence varies. In both studies, jurors were more likely to choose a Not Proven verdict over a Not Guilty verdict when the alternative was available. When evidence against the defendant was only moderately strong and a Not Proven verdict option was available (Study 2), there was also a significant reduction in the conviction rate. Results also showed that understanding of the Not Proven verdict was poor, highlighting inadequacies in the nature of judicial instructions relating to this verdict.Keywords
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Polygraph Evidence and Juror Judgments: The Effects of Corroborating Evidence1Journal of Applied Social Psychology, 2003
- Trying Hard or Hardly Trying: An Analysis of Context Effects in ChoiceJournal of Consumer Psychology, 2000
- Effects of reasonable doubt definition and inclusion of a lesser charge on jury verdicts.Law and Human Behavior, 1999
- The Scottish Criminal Jury: A Very Peculiar InstitutionLaw and Contemporary Problems, 1999
- Context-Dependent Selection: The Effects of Decoy and Phantom Job CandidatesOrganizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes, 1996
- The Attraction Effect and Political Choice in Two ElectionsJournal of Consumer Psychology, 1995
- Beliefs About Forensic HypnosisInternational Journal of Clinical and Experimental Hypnosis, 1986
- Reanalysis of Vidmar's data on the effects of decision alternatives on verdicts of simulated jurors.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1975
- Effects of decision alternatives on the verdicts and social perceptions of simulated jurors.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1972
- Latitude and Severity of Sentencing Options, Race of the Victim and Decisions of Simulated Jurors: Some Issues Arising from the “Algiers Motel” TrialLaw & Society Review, 1972