Realist evaluation of factors affecting the retention of the mental health workforce: building a realist programme theory
Open Access
Abstract
Objective The shortage of mental healthcare workforce is a global problem. Mental health services have higher staff turnover and more vacancies than the health sector average. In this study, we developed, tested and refined an initial programme theory (IPT) to offer insight into mechanisms that affect staff retention in UK mental health provider organisations. Design A realist evaluation to identify the contexts and mechanisms that impacted on workforce retention. We developed an IPT through a realist review and stakeholder engagement. Setting We then tested the IPT through a realist evaluation in six case studies in selected National Health Service (NHS) mental health Trusts in England. Sites were selected to give variation in retention rates; quality ratings were awarded by the national healthcare regulator, staff satisfaction levels and geography. Participants Realist interviews (199) were conducted with senior executives and registered mental health clinicians. Data were analysed using an iterative realist approach to analyse the links between the context, mechanism and outcomes and test and revise initial programme theories. The study has been reported in line with Realist And Meta-narrative Evidence Syntheses: Evolving Standards (RAMESES) II guidelines. Results Data allowed us to refine the IPT. Workplace contexts influenced the key mechanisms of ‘perceived quality of care and the ability to make a difference’, ‘psychological safety’, ‘feeling valued’ and ‘feeling connected’, all of which influenced intention to leave. Conclusions The final programme theory highlighting key contexts and mechanisms for improving retention among mental health staff in the NHS is presented. Organisational culture underlies all other contexts and mechanisms.Keywords
Funding Information
- The Health Foundation (1275277)
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Mental health services face “vicious cycle” of staff shortages, MPs warnBMJ, 2023
- Realist synthesis of factors affecting retention of staff in UK adult mental health servicesBMJ Open, 2023
- Moral injury and psychological wellbeing in UK healthcare staffJournal of Mental Health, 2023
- Understanding the factors that affect retention within the mental health nursing workforce: a systematic review and thematic synthesisInternational Journal of Mental Health Nursing, 2021
- Moral injury in healthcare professionals: A scoping review and discussionNursing Ethics, 2021
- An integrative review of nursing staff experiences in high secure forensic mental health settings: Implications for recruitment and retention strategiesJournal of Advanced Nursing, 2020
- No Blame No Gain? From a No Blame Culture to a Responsibility Culture in MedicineJournal of Applied Philosophy, 2020
- The relationship between workforce characteristics and perception of quality of care in mental health: A qualitative studyInternational Journal of Nursing Studies, 2019
- Interventions that promote retention of experienced registered nurses in health care settings: a systematic reviewJournal of Nursing Management, 2013
- How Do You Modernize a Health Service? A Realist Evaluation of Whole‐Scale Transformation in LondonThe Milbank Quarterly, 2009