Word meaning biases or language-specific effects? Evidence from English, Spanish and Korean
Authors:
- 1 April 1997
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in First Language
- Vol. 17 (51) , 031-56
Abstract
This study examines the hypothesis that children learning distinct languages will show differential adherence to proposed word- meaning, biases. English-, Spanish-, and Korean-speaking pre schoolers were tested for their extension of new nouns to referents that shared shape, substance and/or functional properties with the initial referent. English- and Spanish-speaking subjects performed differently from Korean-speaking children. Korean speakers gave more substance-based responses than the other groups, and their responses took functional information into account, while those of Spanish and English speakers did not. Results lend support to the position that children's first best guesses about the meanings of new words are dependent on the structure of the language they are learning, and they challenge the notion that children have universal word learning biases.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Ontological categories and function: Acquisition of new namesCognitive Development, 1995
- The Principle of Mutual Exclusivity in Word Learning: To Honor or Not to Honor?Child Development, 1990
- Do linguistic differences lead to cognitive differences? A cross-linguistic study of semantic and cognitive developmentFirst Language, 1990
- Constraints and development: A reply to Nelson (1988)Cognitive Development, 1990
- On the pragmatics of contrastJournal of Child Language, 1990
- Priorities in Children's Expectations about Object Label Reference: Form over ColorChild Development, 1989
- On the logic of contrastJournal of Child Language, 1988
- The contrastive hypothesis for the acquisition of word meaning: a reconsideration of the theoryJournal of Child Language, 1987
- Evaluating competing linguistic theories with child language data: The case of the mass-count distinctionLinguistics and Philosophy, 1986
- Ensembles and the Formal Semantic Properties of Mass Terms1979