The Macrostructure of Informal Arguments: A Proposed Model and Analysis
Open Access
- 1 August 2003
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in The Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section A
- Vol. 56 (6) , 1021-1051
Abstract
Theories of informal reasoning and critical thinking often maintain that everyday, informal arguments can be classified into types based on the specific organization that the premises or reasons enter into in their support for the conclusion (Snoeck Henkemans, 2000; Vorobej, 1995b). Three general types are identified: convergent, coordinately linked, and subordinately linked arguments. There has been no empirical research, however, to determine whether these structural distinctions have any psychological reality. In the first two of four experiments, college students were presented with premise pairs from larger, informal arguments and were asked to judge the nature of the relationship between the premises in a pair. The judgments involved applying “tests” of linkage, subordination, and so on, that have been proposed in the theoretical literature on argument analysis (e.g., Walton, 1996a; Yanal, 1991). Results suggest that adults can effectively distinguish between linked (interdependent) and convergent relationships and can further distinguish between interdependencies that are full and those that are merely partial. Adults also distinguished between subordinate and nonsubordinate relations. Experiments 3 and 4 provide evidence that adults make use of information about argument structure in evaluating argument strength and in categorizing arguments. Experiment 4 further suggests that facility with macrostructure is only modestly related to deductive reasoning competence. Findings are framed in terms of a speculative account of how argument structure is identified and mentally represented.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Training Propositional ReasoningThe Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology Section A, 2000
- Informal Reasoning and Burden of ProofApplied Cognitive Psychology, 1996
- Mental models and probabilistic thinkingCognition, 1994
- Personal factors influencing informal reasoning of economic issues and the effect of specific instructions.Journal of Educational Psychology, 1993
- Freeman`s Dialectics and the Macrostructure of ArgumentInformal Logic, 1992
- On the Distinction between Convergent and Linked ArgumentsInformal Logic, 1991
- Quantifying SupportInformal Logic, 1991
- Approaches to studying formal and everyday reasoning.Psychological Bulletin, 1989
- Pragmatic reasoning schemasCognitive Psychology, 1985
- Philosophy of Logics1978