Cost effectiveness of proton versus photon radiation therapy with respect to the risk of growth hormone deficiency in children
Open Access
- 29 January 2015
- Vol. 121 (10) , 1694-1702
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Proton therapy in pediatrics may improve the risk/benefit profile of radiotherapy at a greater upfront financial cost, but it may prove to be cost effective if chronic medical complications can be avoided. Tools to assist with decision making are needed to aid in selecting pediatric patients for protons, and cost‐effectiveness models can provide an objective method for this.METHODS: A Markov cohort‐simulation model was developed to assess the expected costs and effectiveness for specific radiation doses to the hypothalamus with protons versus photons in pediatric patients. Costing data included cost of investment and the diagnosis and management of growth hormone deficiency. Longitudinal outcomes data were used to inform risk parameters for the model. With costs in 2012 US dollars and effectiveness measured in quality‐adjusted life years, incremental cost‐effectiveness ratios were used to measure outcomes.RESULTS: Proton therapy was cost effective for some scenarios based on the difference in hypothalamic sparing. Although some scenarios were not cost effective, others were not only cost effective for proton therapy but also demonstrated that protons were cost saving compared with photons.CONCLUSIONS: The current results provide the first evidence‐based guide for identifying children with brain tumors who may benefit the most from proton therapy with respect to endocrine dysfunction. Proton therapy may be more cost effective for scenarios in which radiation dose to the hypothalamus can be spared, but protons may not be cost effective when tumors are involving or directly adjacent to the hypothalamus if there is a high dose to this structure. Cancer 2015;121:1694–1702. © 2015 American Cancer Society.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cost effectiveness of proton therapy compared with photon therapy in the management of pediatric medulloblastomaCancer, 2013
- Is spending on proton beam therapy for cancer going too far, too fast?BMJ, 2012
- Growth Hormone Secretion After Conformal Radiation Therapy in Pediatric Patients With Localized Brain TumorsJournal of Clinical Oncology, 2011
- Proton Therapy in the Clinic2011
- A review of the impact of photon and proton external beam radiotherapy treatment modalities on the dose distribution in field and out-of-field; implications for the long-term morbidity of cancer survivorsActa Oncologica, 2007
- Cost-utility of somatropin (rDNA origin) in the treatment of growth hormone deficiency in childrenCurrent Medical Research and Opinion, 2005
- Proton beam therapyBritish Journal of Cancer, 2005
- Use of Cost-Effectiveness Analysis in Health-Care Resource Allocation Decision-Making: How Are Cost-Effectiveness Thresholds Expected to Emerge?Value in Health, 2004
- Real-Time Rationing of Scarce Resources: The Northeast Proton Therapy Center ExperienceJournal of Clinical Oncology, 2004
- Markov Models in Medical Decision MakingMedical Decision Making, 1993