LEARNERS' USES OF TWO TYPES OF WRITTEN FEEDBACK ON A L2 WRITING REVISION TASK
Authors:
- 26 January 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Studies in Second Language Acquisition
- Vol. 29 (1) , 67-100
Abstract
This study examines the effectiveness of written error corrections versus reformulations of second language learners' writing as two means of improving learners' grammatical accuracy on a three-stage composition-comparison-revision task. Concurrent verbal protocols were employed during the comparison stage in order to study the learners' reported awareness of the more targetlike reformulations. The reactivity of think-alouds as a research tool was also assessed. First, 15 adult learners of English participated in a repeated-measures study with three experimental conditions: error correction, reformulation, and reformulation + think-aloud. Participant reports of awareness in the reformulation + think-aloud condition suggested that noticing of feedback was related to the accuracy of subsequent revisions. A second nonrepeated-measures study was then carried out with 54 participants; a control group was added and the design was modified in an attempt to eliminate the reported tendency of learners to develop and use memorization strategies while processing the written feedback. In both experiments, participants performed significantly better in the error correction condition than in the reformulation condition. The think-alouds, used to examine learners' attentional processes, were found to be reactive in the first study; learners in the reformulation condition produced significantly more accurate revisions than those who were asked to think aloud while processing the reformulations they received. The results suggest that whereas verbal protocols might be able to shed some light on learner-internal processes in relation to written feedback, they should be employed and interpreted with care.Keywords
This publication has 56 references indexed in Scilit:
- Recasts in the Adult English L2 Classroom: Characteristics, Explicitness, and EffectivenessThe Modern Language Journal, 2006
- RECASTS AND SECOND LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENTStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 2003
- NEGATIVE FEEDBACK AND POSITIVE EVIDENCE IN TASK-BASED INTERACTIONStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 2003
- Do Learners Notice Enhanced Forms while Interacting with the L2?: An Online and Offline Study of the Role of Written Input Enhancement in L2 ReadingHispania, 2001
- Incidental vocabulary acquisition in a second language: the construct of task-induced involvementApplied Linguistics, 2001
- The Role of Interaction in Native Speaker Comprehension of Nonnative Speaker SpeechThe Modern Language Journal, 1998
- Sequencing in SLAStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 1996
- Attention in Cognitive Science and Second Language AcquisitionStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 1994
- Learner self-correction in EFL written compositionsELT Journal, 1993
- Salience of Feedback on Error and Its Effect on EFL Writing QualityTESOL Quarterly, 1986