“Force,” ontology, and language
Authors:
- David T. BrookesDBDavid T. Brookes
- Eugenia EtkinaEEEugenia Etkina
Open Access
- 25 June 2009
- journal article
- Published by American Physical Society (APS) in Physical Review Special Topics - Physics Education Research
- Vol. 5 (1)
Abstract
We introduce a linguistic framework through which one can interpret systematically students’ understanding of and reasoning about force and motion. Some researchers have suggested that students have robust misconceptions or alternative frameworks grounded in everyday experience. Others have pointed out the inconsistency of students’ responses and presented a phenomenological explanation for what is observed, namely, knowledge in pieces. We wish to present a view that builds on and unifies aspects of this prior research. Our argument is that many students’ difficulties with force and motion are primarily due to a combination of linguistic and ontological difficulties. It is possible that students are primarily engaged in trying to define and categorize the meaning of the term “force” as spoken about by physicists. We found that this process of negotiation of meaning is remarkably similar to that engaged in by physicists in history. In this paper we will describe a study of the historical record that reveals an analogous process of meaning negotiation, spanning multiple centuries. Using methods from cognitive linguistics and systemic functional grammar, we will present an analysis of the force and motion literature, focusing on prior studies with interview data. We will then discuss the implications of our findings for physics instructionKeywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- The effect of context on students’ reasoning about forcesInternational Journal of Science Education, 1997
- Concepts in force and motionThe Physics Teacher, 1990
- Common sense concepts about motionAmerican Journal of Physics, 1985
- Research on conceptual understanding in mechanicsPhysics Today, 1984
- Intuitive PhysicsScientific American, 1983
- Concepts, Misconceptions and Alternative Conceptions: Changing Perspectives in Science EducationStudies in Science Education, 1983
- Accommodation of a scientific conception: Toward a theory of conceptual changeScience Education, 1982
- Naive beliefs in “sophisticated” subjects: misconceptions about trajectories of objectsCognition, 1981
- Curvilinear Motion in the Absence of External Forces: Naïve Beliefs About the Motion of ObjectsScience, 1980
- Factors influencing the learning of classical mechanicsAmerican Journal of Physics, 1980