COHERENCE AND CORRESPONDENCE IN THE NETWORK DYNAMICS OF BELIEF SUITES

Authors:
  • AMAndrew Modell
    Andrew Modell
  • NBNicholas Breslin
    Nicholas Breslin
  • JMJasmine Mcnenny
    Jasmine Mcnenny
  • IMIrina Mondescu
    Irina Mondescu
  • KFKyle Finnegan
    Kyle Finnegan
  • RORobert Olsen
    Robert Olsen
  • CAChanyu An
    Chanyu An
  • AFAlexander Fedder
    Alexander Fedder

Abstract
Coherence and correspondence are classical contenders as theories of truth. In this paper we examine them instead as interacting factors in the dynamics of belief across epistemic networks. We construct an agent-based model of network contact in which agents are characterized not in terms of single beliefs but in terms of internal beliefsuites. Individuals update elements of their belief suites on input from other agents in order both to maximize internal belief coherence and to incorporate ‘trickled in’ elements of truth as correspondence. Results, though often intuitive, prove more complex than in simpler models (Hegselmann and Krause 2002, 2006; Grimet al. 2015). The optimistic finding is that pressures toward internal coherence can exploit and expand on small elements of truth as correspondence is introduced into epistemic networks. Less optimistic results show that pressures for coherence can also work directly against the incorporation of truth, particularly when coherence is established first and new data are introduced later.

This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit: