Competing Visions of Ethical AI: A Case Study of OpenAI
Authors:
- Melissa WilfleyMWMelissa Wilfley
- Mengting AiMAMengting Ai
- Madelyn Rose SanfilippoMSMadelyn Rose Sanfilippo
Preprint
Abstract
Introduction. AI Ethics is framed distinctly across actors and stakeholder groups. We report results from a case study of OpenAI analysing ethical AI discourse. Method. Research addressed: How has OpenAI's public discourse leveraged 'ethics', 'safety', 'alignment' and adjacent related concepts over time, and what does discourse signal about framing in practice? A structured corpus, differentiating between communication for a general audience and communication with an academic audience, was assembled from public documentation. Analysis. Qualitative content analysis of ethical themes combined inductively derived and deductively applied codes. Quantitative analysis leveraged computational content analysis methods via NLP to model topics and quantify changes in rhetoric over time. Visualizations report aggregate results. For reproducible results, we have released our code at https://github.com/famous-blue-raincoat/AI_Ethics_Discourse. Results. Results indicate that safety and risk discourse dominate OpenAI's public communication and documentation, without applying academic and advocacy ethics frameworks or vocabularies. Conclusions. Implications for governance are presented, along with discussion of ethics-washing practices in industry.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Responsible artificial intelligence governance: A review and research frameworkThe Journal of Strategic Information Systems, 2025
- The ethical wisdom of AI developersAI and Ethics, 2024
- AI Ethics, Ethics Washing, and the Need to Politicize Data EthicsDigital Society, 2022
- The Ethics of AI Ethics. A Constructive CritiquePhilosophy & Technology, 2022
- From Greenwashing to Machinewashing: A Model and Future Directions Derived from Reasoning by AnalogyJournal of Business Ethics, 2022
- Ethics as a Service: A Pragmatic Operationalisation of AI EthicsMinds and Machines, 2021
- Research and Practice of AI Ethics: A Case Study Approach Juxtaposing Academic Discourse with Organisational RealityScience and Engineering Ethics, 2021
- Organisational responses to the ethical issues of artificial intelligenceAI & SOCIETY, 2021
- Principles alone cannot guarantee ethical AINature Machine Intelligence, 2019
- The global landscape of AI ethics guidelinesNature Machine Intelligence, 2019