Abstract
Leading scholarship consistently shows citizens prefer high-skilled immigrants, with implications for theorizing immigration attitudes. Without contesting this, we argue it ignores a crucial aspect of occupations that transcends skills: their essentialness to core economic and social functions. Leveraging the COVID-19 pandemic as a shock that revealed some occupations’ pre-existing essential qualities, particularly those disproportionately comprising immigrant workers, we show how this feature matters for mass preferences on labor migration. Our evidence comes from a conjoint experiment fielded during 2021 in the UK, one of the worst-affected countries globally. Respondents are 22 percentage points more likely to admit immigrants working in essential over non-essential occupations—with nationalities at the lower end of a perceived ethnic hierarchy benefiting significantly more, and particularly among respondents likely to hold more prejudice against immigrants. Our study contributes new theorization about the drivers of immigration attitudes during and beyond crises, with implications for labor migration policymaking.
Keywords