Improved Bootstrap Confidence Limits in Large-Scale Phylogenies, with an Example from Neo-Astragalus (Leguminosae)
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 December 2000
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Systematic Biology
- Vol. 49 (4) , 671-685
Abstract
Phylogenetic analyses of large data sets pose special challenges, including the apparent tendency for the bootstrap support for a clade to decline with increased taxon sampling of that clade. We document this decline in data sets with increasing numbers of taxa in Astragalus, the most species-rich angiosperm genus. Support for one subclade, Neo-Astragalus, declined monotonically with increased sampling of taxa inside Neo-Astragalus, irrespective of whether parsimony or neighbor-joining methods were used or of which particular heuristic search algorithm was used (although more stringent algorithms tended to yield higher support). Three possible explanations for this decline were examined, including (1) mistaken assignment of the most recent common ancestor of the taxon sample (and its bootstrap support) with the most recent common ancestor of the clade from which it was sampled; (2) computational limitations of heuristic search strategies; and (3) statistical bias in bootstrap proportions, especially that from random homoplasy distributed among taxa. The best explanation appears to be (3), although computational shortcomings (2) may explain some of the problem. The bootstrap proportion, as currently used in phylogenetic analysis, does not accurately capture the classical notion of confidence assessments on the null hypothesis of nonmonophyly, especially in large data sets. More accurate assessments of confidence as type I error levels (relying on iterated bootstrap methods) remove most of the monotonic decline in confidence with increasing numbers of taxa.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Taxon sampling revisitedNature, 1999
- Large-Scale Phylogenies and Measuring the Performance of Phylogenetic EstimatorsSystematic Biology, 1998
- Sensitivity of Phylogeny Estimation to Taxonomic SamplingSystematic Biology, 1998
- Bootstrapping phylogenies: Large deviations and dispersion effectsBiometrika, 1996
- Estimation of evolutionary distances between nucleotide sequencesJournal of Molecular Evolution, 1994
- The phylogenetic position of the genus Astragalus (fabaceae): Evidence from the chloroplast genes rpoC1 and rpoC2Biochemical Systematics and Ecology, 1994
- Calibrating the bootstrap test of monophylyInternational Journal for Parasitology, 1993
- Statistical properties of bootstrap estimation of phylogenetic variability from nucleotide sequences. I. Four taxa with a molecular clock.Molecular Biology and Evolution, 1992
- The number of replications needed for accurate estimation of the bootstrap P value in phylogenetic studies.Molecular Biology and Evolution, 1992
- Unlikelihood that minimal phylogenies for a realistic biological study can be constructed in reasonable computational timeMathematical Biosciences, 1982