Assessment of the Accuracy of ISRIC and ESDAC Soil Texture Data Compared to the Soil Map of Greece: A Statistical and Spatial Approach to Identify Sources of Differences
Authors:
- Stylianos GerontidisStylianos Gerontidis
- Konstantinos X. SoulisKonstantinos X. Soulis
- Alexandros StavropoulosAlexandros Stavropoulos
- Evangelos NikitakisENEvangelos Nikitakis
- Dionissios P. KalivasDionissios P. Kalivas
- Orestis KairisOKOrestis Kairis
- Dimitrios KopanelisDKDimitrios Kopanelis
- Xenofon K. SoulisXSXenofon K. Soulis
- Stergia Palli-GravaniStergia Palli-Gravani
Open Access
- 25 November 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Soil Systems
- Vol. 9 (4) , 133
Abstract
Soil maps are essential for managing Earth’s resources, but the accuracy of widely used global and pan-European digital soil maps in heterogeneous landscapes remains a critical concern. This study provides a comprehensive evaluation of two prominent datasets, ISRIC-SoilGrids and the European Soil Data Centre (ESDAC), by comparing their soil texture predictions against the detailed Greek National Soil Map, which is based on over 10,000 field samples. The results from statistical and spatial analyses reveal significant discrepancies and weak correlations, with a very low overall accuracy for soil texture class prediction (19–21%) and high Root Mean Square Error (RMSE) values ranging from 13% to 19%. The global models failed to capture local variability, showing very low explanatory power (R2 < 0.2) and systematically underrepresenting soils with extreme textures. Furthermore, these prediction errors are not entirely random but are significantly clustered in hot spots linked to distinct parent materials and geomorphological features. Our findings demonstrate that while invaluable for large-scale assessments, the direct application of global soil databases for regional policy or precision agriculture in a geologically complex country like Greece is subject to considerable uncertainty, highlighting the critical need for local calibration and the integration of national datasets to improve the reliability of soil information.Keywords
Funding Information
- European Commission (101156867)
- Hellenic Foundation for Research and Innovation (H.F.R.I.; ELIDEK) through the project “DT-AGRO–Spatially Explicit Digital Twin of the Greek Agro-Hydro-System” (014815)
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Influence of Agricultural Land Use Management on Soil Particle Size Distribution and Nutrient Adsorption in Western KenyaChemistry Africa, 2025
- Effects of parent material on soil hydraulic properties in subtropical hilly area of Southern ChinaCATENA, 2024
- Map-based soil crusting susceptibility assessment using pedotransfer Rules, CORINE and NDVI: A preliminary study in GreeceEcological Indicators, 2023
- Exploring the spatial patterns of soil salinity and organic carbon in agricultural areas of Lesvos Island, Greece, using geoinformation technologiesEnvironmental Monitoring and Assessment, 2023
- Evaluation of global and continental scale soil maps for southern Africa using selected soil propertiesCATENA, 2022
- The importance of parent material in soil classification: A review in a historical contextCATENA, 2019
- Compositional Data Analysis2011
- Parent material effects on Mediterranean woodland ecosystems in NE SpainCATENA, 2005
- A review of assessing the accuracy of classifications of remotely sensed dataRemote Sensing of Environment, 1991
- Effects of acidic and basic parent materials on formation of some soils in Quebec (Canada)Geoderma, 1984