Abstract
Sustainable finance has long been the subject of considerable disagreement. This chapter seeks to shed light on these disagreements by focusing on (a) what people disagree about, (b) why they disagree and (c) how best to address disagreements. Rather than treating disagreement as a flaw to be fixed, the authors suggest that it may be inherent to sustainable finance, reflecting the concept’s appraisive, internally complex and open-ended character. The authors identify three attributes that underpin disagreements in sustainable finance: values concerning what people consider important or desirable; beliefs about sustainability and appropriate responses; and interests representing the outcomes different actors seek to achieve. The chapter invites readers to adopt a more reflexive approach, asking questions of themselves and others when engaging in debates and controversies. A core argument is that a better understanding of why people disagree places us in a stronger position to move beyond entrenched positions and to identify common ground and collective expectations for sustainable finance.