Healthy gut microbiomes are host-controllable microbiomes

Authors:

Abstract
Introduction"The instinct of each species is good for itself but has never, as far as we can judge, been produced for the exclusive good of others" (1). Why, then, do humans and other mammals benefit from their microbes?Evolutionary theory predicts that natural selection can act at organizational levels higher than the gene or individual—such as on groups or even species—provided that the selective advantages for the group outweigh evolutionary conflicts. Darwin suggested that natural selection can act "on the family, and not the individual," "for the sake of gaining a serviceable end" (1). This idea was later formalized as kin selection (2). Even distantly related organisms can align their evolutionary goals, as demonstrated by the longstanding partnership between eukaryotic cells and mitochondria (3).Microbes are an integral part of animal and plant hosts, fulfilling essential physiological roles, such as enabling access to otherwise unavailable nutrients, training the immune system, supporting mucosal development, and providing protection. Some microbes are even vertically transmitted from parents to offspring. The numerous examples of microbes performing vital functions for their macrobial hosts makes it tempting to assume that humans and the microbes residing on and within our bodies—particularly in our guts—evolved to share common selective interests that outweigh potential evolutionary conflicts (4–7). Supporting this assumption, several reports suggest that humans and other mammals are selected for harboring "good" microbes and that these "good" microbes thrive by helping their hosts, for example, by contributing over 95% of our organism's genetic repertoire (7–9). But is group-level selection a necessary and sufficient mechanism to explain why microbiomes benefit their hosts?Microbes certainly influence a host's chances of survival and reproductive success (10,11) but the reasons why microbes would reduce their own fitness to form an evolutionarily aligned group with their hosts and other microbial populations—an essential condition for group-level selection—are not easily explained (12,13). For example, during a 25-year human generation, gut microbes undergo more than 50,000 generations (assuming a conservative four-hour generation time), competing with thousands of microbial species. Roughly half of the bacterial biomass in the colon is lost daily and replaced by new bacterial growth (14,15). Before a human reproduces, any trait unfavorable to a microbe's growth or survival would likely be eliminated. Moreover, the human gut is a relatively open system, regularly exposed to diverse environmental microbes. Vertical transmission accounts for only a small fraction of the microbiome. About twenty species are consistently shared among most adults (16). How, then, has evolution shaped such a diverse, rapidly evolving microbial ecosystem to consistently benefit individual health?One might argue that by providing advantages to "good" microbes, the host mitigates evolutionary conflicts, encouraging microbes to sacrifice some fitness for the host’s benefit. However, as microbes rapidly evolve, new genotypes with similar needs can emerge to exploit these host-provided advantages without incurring costs—an example of the tragedy of the commons (17). These benefits are shared among all compatible microbes, whether or not they contribute to the host’s well-being, creating an imbalance between contributors and free riders. A free rider, for example, could be a bacterium that feeds on mucin glycans provided by the host while invading tissue and potentially causing severe illness.Why, then, do humans and other mammals benefit from their microbes? A recent model by Sharp & Foster suggests that one way to overcome this evolutionary conundrum is for hosts to evolve mechanisms to actively control their microbes and limit the opportunities for microbes to evade control (18). This would require mechanisms of enforcement or policing to maintain cooperation (19). In this view, hosts are selected not for harboring "beneficial" microbes but for their ability to maintain their microbiomes in a healthy state. In other words, evolution might favor hosts as microbiome control engineers—or, more accurately, control tinkerers (20)—who make use of various control methods within reach of the evolutionary landscape to sustain their microbiomes in a healthy state. These include responses ranging from rudimentary mechanisms such as inflammation or diarrhea to the sophisticated responses driven by the adaptive immune system. From this perspective, control theory—the study of how systems regulate themselves to achieve desired outcomes—parallels host-microbial interactions, suggesting that healthy microbiomes might be, by definition, host-controllable microbiomes.Will a large complex microbiome be stable?In the 1970s, writing in Nature, Robert May proposed a limit to the stability of ecosystems as complexity increases, particularly as the number and strength of species interactions grow (21). May analyzed a simplified Generalized Lotka-Volterra (GLV) model to explore this concept. The model simulates random communities where population sizes are constrained by resource availability (represented as negative self-interactions) and by mutual positive or negative influences on one another’s growth. According to the GLV model, assembled communities are predicted to remain stable only when interactions are sufficiently weak or when strong interactions are confined to a few species (Figure 1). GLV-like models are commonly applied to the study of microbiomes, where similar stability/complexity trade-offs are assumed to hold (22,23). However, even in May's simplified model, introducing a controller—an agent that directs the system toward a predetermined objective, such as through energy expenditure—is one way to...
Funding Information
  • Agence Nationale de la Recherche

This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit: