Is invalid voting more common in complex electoral systems than in simpler ones? An examination of mixed systems and first-past-the-post systems
Author:
Open Access
- 1 April 2026
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Public Choice
Abstract
This study examines the level of invalid voting in mixed electoral systems in comparison with the level of such voting in First-Past-The-Post (FPTP) systems. High levels of invalid votes can indicate problems with the electoral system used and can weaken the legitimacy of elections. Theoretically, a higher level of invalid votes can be linked to elections in which a complex electoral system, such as a mixed system, is used. Conversely, lower levels of invalid voting can be linked to elections in which a simple electoral system, such as a FPTP system, is used. We carry out a large, global, cross-national empirical comparison of invalid voting for national parliaments worldwide that covers more than six decades. First, we examine whether the level of invalid voting is higher in mixed systems than in FPTP systems. Second, we examine whether the level is higher in countries that currently use mixed systems but previously used FPTP systems or were formerly non-independent states. The results show that invalid voting is more prevalent in mixed systems than in FPTP systems. They also illustrate that invalid voting is more prevalent when countries transition from a FPTP system to a mixed electoral system, or when they adopt a mixed system following full independence or the restoration of sovereignty. In the persistent debate about which electoral system is preferable, invalid voting rates represent one of several indicators of system quality, and according to this measure, FPTP systems outperform mixed systems.Keywords
Funding Information
- Mittuniversitetet
This publication has 52 references indexed in Scilit:
- Parties’ and voters’ dilemmas under Italy’s new mixed electoral systemPublic Choice, 2025
- Hybrid choice systems in small-n elections with sophisticated electoratesPublic Choice, 2025
- The spectacular enlargement of the Bundestag and the long road to the 2023 German electoral law reformPublic Choice, 2025
- Cancellation of overhang seats: the price of unkept promisesPublic Choice, 2025
- The “hacking” of a mixed electoral system: a case study of HungaryPublic Choice, 2025
- Voter disengagement and dissatisfaction under Japan’s mixed electoral systemPublic Choice, 2025
- The legacy of the past: pre-reform party competition and contamination of single-member districts in mixed electoral systemsPublic Choice, 2025
- How does the introduction of mixed electoral systems influence women’s representation in parliaments?Public Choice, 2025
- The paradox of the mixed semi-compensatory system in South Korea: gaming the system or toeing the mark?Public Choice, 2025
- Overvotes, Overranks, and Skips: Mismarked and Rejected Votes in Ranked Choice VotingPolitical Behavior, 2025