Penal extractivism: A qualitative study on punishment and extractive industries in Peru
Authors:
Open Access
- 8 June 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Punishment & Society
- Vol. 27 (1) , 147-171
Abstract
This article introduces the concept of penal extractivism in the punishment and society literature. We define penal extractivism as the punitive strategies that a state implements to safeguard extractive industries from citizens’ contention. This concept addresses the limitations of categories like criminalization, protest policing, social control, and labour discipline while bridging the gap between punishment studies and research on extractive industries. Additionally, we draw upon evidence of the Espinar mining conflict in Peru to explain five punitive strategies the state uses to handle protests: (1) off-duty policing and critical assets legislation, (2) state of emergency declarations, (3) police or prosecutorial notes against environmental defenders, (4) criminal indictments, and (5) the transferring of criminal cases to distant jurisdictions. Based on our findings, we argue that penal extractivism is a dynamic and ambivalent project that targets marginalized rural populations. The state partially deters mobilizations but fails to address the underlying social unrest, reinforcing the conditions that perpetuate mining conflicts. This in-depth within-case analysis examines the relationship between punishment and extractivism in the global context of contemporary social mobilizations.Keywords
Funding Information
- Dean's International & Indigenous Initiatives Fund - University of Toronto
- CrimSL Research Cluster for the Study of Racism and Inequality - University of Toronto
This publication has 61 references indexed in Scilit:
- Mining and violence in Latin America: The state’s coercive responses to anti-mining resistanceWorld Development, 2023
- One industry, different conflicts: A typology of mining mobilizationThe Extractive Industries and Society, 2022
- Beyond the ‘Neo-liberal Penality Thesis’? Punitive Turn and Political Change in South America2018
- Cycle of Abundance and Institutional Pathways2017
- Why do some communities resist mining projects while others do not?The Extractive Industries and Society, 2017
- The glocalization of mining conflict: Cases from PeruThe Extractive Industries and Society, 2016
- The extractive imperative in Latin AmericaThe Extractive Industries and Society, 2016
- The rebirth of the prison in Latin America: determinants, regimes and social effectsCrime, Law and Social Change, 2015
- Group Inequalities and the Nature and Power of Collective Action: Case Studies from PeruWorld Development, 2007
- Public order policing: A tough act to follow?International Journal of the Sociology of Law, 2005