Does healthcare system device volume correlate with price paid for spinal implants: a cross-sectional analysis of a national purchasing database
Authors:
Open Access
Abstract
Objectives Amid continuously rising US healthcare costs, particularly for inpatient and surgical services, strategies to more effectively manage supply chain expenses are urgently necessary. Across industries, the ‘economy of scale’ principle indicates that larger purchasing volumes should correspond to lower prices due to ‘bulk discounts’. Even as such advantages of scale have driven health system mergers in the USA, it is not clear whether they are being achieved, including for specialised products like surgical implants which may be more vulnerable to cost inefficiency. The objective of this observational cross-sectional study was to investigate whether purchasing volumes for spinal implants was correlated with price paid. Setting USA. Participants Market data based on pricing levels for spine implants were reviewed from industry implant price databases. Filters were applied to narrow the sample to include comparable institutions based on procedural volume, patient characteristics and geographical considerations. Information on the attributes of 619 health systems representing 12 471 provider locations was derived from national databases and analytics platforms. Primary outcome measure Institution-specific price index paid for spinal implants, normalised to the national average price point achieved. Results A Spearman’s correlation test indicated a weak relationship between purchasing volume and price index paid (ρ=−0.35, pConclusions National supply chain data revealed that there was no significant relationship between purchasing volume and price paid by health systems for spinal implants. These findings suggest that factors other than purchasing or patient volume are responsible for setting prices paid by health systems to surgical vendors and/or larger healthcare systems are not negotiating in a way to consistently achieve optimal pricing.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Variation in Costs of Spinal Implants in United States Academic Medical CentersSpine, 2016
- Damage control orthopaedics: Variability of construct design for external fixation of the lower extremity and implications on costInjury, 2015
- The Industrial Organization of Health-Care MarketsJournal of Economic Literature, 2015
- Is the System Really the Solution? Operating Costs in Hospital SystemsMedical Care Research and Review, 2015
- Bargaining Ability and Competitive Advantage: Empirical Evidence from Medical DevicesManagement Science, 2014
- Quantifying opportunities for hospital cost control: medical device purchasing and patient discharge planning.2014
- Variability in Costs Associated with Total Hip and Knee Replacement ImplantsJournal of Bone and Joint Surgery, 2012
- The Impact of Group Purchasing Organizations on Healthcare-Product Supply ChainsManufacturing & Service Operations Management, 2012
- Implant vendors and hospitalsHealth Care Management Review, 2009
- Where Are the Costs in Perioperative Care?: Analysis of Hospital Costs and Charges for Inpatient Surgical CareAnesthesiology, 1995