Ethics and Ethical Critique in the Archaeology of Modern Conflict
- 1 October 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Norwegian Archaeological Review
- Vol. 41 (2) , 159-175
Abstract
Archaeological work on the remains of 20th century conflict presents a unique and challenging set of ethical problems that have yet to be explicitly addressed. These are prompted by working with witnesses and survivors, the often violent contestation of war memory narratives, questions of media and public representation, and our own political agendas. In light of these issues I argue here for a lively and dynamic ethical debate within the discipline of modern conflict archaeology. We need to move beyond the well‐meaning platitudes of a redemptive ethics towards a more critical, transgressive model. I outline some of the key areas and issues for such a wide‐ranging ethical discourse, summarized as a set of questions or discussion points. Finally I consider the possibility of a critical ethics for modern conflict archaeology, drawing on Judith Butler's model of critique as ethical praxis. Throughout this discussion I argue that the controversy inherent in modern conflict archaeology is its greatest strength, because it forces us to take a position of critical self‐awareness both as individual practitioners and as a discipline.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Origins and Ethics of Maritime Archaeology – Part IPublic Archaeology, 2007
- Multidisciplinary investigations at Stalag Luft III allied prisoner‐of‐war camp: The site of the 1944 “great escape,” Zagan, Western PolandGeoarchaeology, 2007
- The Ethics of Archaeology: Philosophical Perspectives on Archaeological Practice, edited by Chris Scarre & Geoffrey Scarre, 2006. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press; ISBN 0-521-84011-2 hardback £45 & US$80; ISBN 0-521-54942-6 paperback £19.99 & US$34.99; xi+318 pp., 1 tableCambridge Archaeological Journal, 2007
- On the History of Man-made Destruction: Loss, Death, Memory, and Germany in the Bombing WarHistory Workshop Journal, 2006
- Archaeology and Respect for the DeadJournal of Applied Philosophy, 2003
- Matériel Culture2003
- Archaeologies that hurt; descendants that matter: A pragmatic approach to collaboration in the public interpretation of African-American archaeologyWorld Archaeology, 2002
- Decoding ethicsPublic Archaeology, 2001
- Buried livesArchaeological Dialogues, 2000
- Bodies of Metal, Shells of MemoryJournal of Material Culture, 2000