The peer review process is central to academic work, yet remains a relatively unex plored, indeed largely secret, activity. Peer review manifests itself in many ways and at a variety of levels in academic life: in staff employment, appraisal and promotion decisions, in research degree assessment, in research and teaching assessment exercises, in the publication process. This paper will focus on the last of these, and, in particular, on the reviews produced for refereed academic journal articles and book proposals. While my own work as a journal editor and referee allows me something of a more general perspective, I will use, for ethical and cathartic reasons, the reviews I have myself received of my own submitted articles and book proposals. The issues to be examined will include the quantity and quality of the advice given, the differences between the reviews of the same paper produced by different reviewers, and the relationship between reviews and editorial decisions. Some suggestions will be offered as to how the reviewing process might be developed and improved.