The sociopolitical discourse on health data sharing in Switzerland: lessons learned from 1992 to 2023 for present public trust building – a multi-method study
Open Access
- 1 June 2025
- journal article
- Published by SMW Supporting Association in Swiss Medical Weekly
- Vol. 155 (6) , 4277
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Public trust is central for the successful implementation of health data sharing initiatives, and it is partly shaped by the public’s past experiences with the system. Understanding how these experiences have framed current public trust is essential to adequately inform trust-building measures in current and future health data sharing initiatives. The aim of the present study was to trace the evolution of the sociopolitical discourse surrounding health data sharing in Switzerland from 1992 to the present by identifying (1) key policy documents; (2) opinion-shaping and (3) negative events influencing public experience and trust in health data sharing over the last 31 years; (4) implementation obstacles and (5) lessons learned throughout this period. The analysis offers the opportunity to reflect on challenges in implementing data sharing initiatives and their impact on public trust, aiming to provide insights for guiding Swiss and European policymakers in designing future health data sharing initiatives while fostering public trust. METHODS: We designed a multi-method study comprising (A.I) a thematic analysis of online interviews with key stakeholders and (A.II) a scoping review of expert opinion papers to capture expert perspectives; (B) a policy analysis of government policies to comprehend the political trajectory of the health data sharing discourse; and (C) an analysis of news articles across eight major Swiss newspapers to trace the evolution of the media narrative around data sharing. RESULTS: While the digitisation of private life in the early 2000s and the COVID-19 pandemic positively influenced Switzerland’s sociopolitical discourse on health data sharing, triggering policy waves on the primary and secondary use of health data, recent setbacks with the Electronic Patient Dossier (EPD) initiative negatively impacted public trust. Key obstacles to EPD implementation were identified across policy, public, professional and technical levels, providing valuable lessons and actionable recommendations for improving the implementation of current and future health data sharing initiatives. CONCLUSIONS: The sociopolitical discourse on health data sharing in Switzerland is mainly framed by past and present negative narratives on the EPD, compounded by national and international scandals. It is recommended to centralise coordination at the federal level and to foster stakeholder collaboration. To build and maintain public trust, comprehensive public engagement strategies and user-friendly solutions that offer citizens autonomy are needed. Also, careful narrative management is essential. Healthcare professionals should be actively involved in the development and policymaking process from the outset and provided with financial support to facilitate their digital transition. Considering the promising health data sharing initiatives under the DigiSanté programme, adopting these recommendations is essential to avoid delays, negative narratives and further erosion of public trust in Switzerland’s health data sharing initiatives.Keywords
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- What does it take to create a European Health Data Space? International commitments and national realitiesZeitschrift für Evidenz, Fortbildung und Qualität im Gesundheitswesen, 2023
- Error 404: looking for trust in international law on digital technologiesLaw, Innovation and Technology, 2023
- Evaluating models of consent in changing health research environmentsMedicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 2022
- Do personal health concerns and trust in healthcare providers mitigate privacy concerns? Effects on patients’ intention to share personal health data on electronic health recordsSocial Science & Medicine, 2021
- Qualitative Research in Health Care2019
- Thematic Analysis2018
- E-health in Switzerland: The laborious adoption of the federal law on electronic health records (EHR) and health information exchange (HIE) networksHealth Policy, 2018
- Trust: The Keystone of the Patient-Physician RelationshipJournal of the American College of Surgeons, 2017
- Political Trust and Sophistication: Taking Measurement SeriouslySocial Indicators Research, 2015
- Scoping studies: towards a methodological frameworkInternational Journal of Social Research Methodology, 2005