Stakeholder Perspectives Regarding Captive Marine Mammals—How Can We Compromise?
- 1 April 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Zoo Biology
- Vol. 44 (3) , 211-220
Abstract
This essay briefly presents the perspectives of multiple stakeholders regarding the care of captive marine mammals. Based on extant literature and professional experiences, the expectations, biases, and obstacles are described for the following perspectives: facilities, staff, guests, activists, scientists, third‐party accreditations, governmental agencies, and marine mammals. All identified human stakeholders advocate for the animals, but the stakeholders have differing perspectives. The purpose of the article is to identify areas of impasse and areas of overlap to identify possible compromises to move toward a less contentious dichotomy. A summary of a recent case study involving the recently deceased killer whale, Tokitae, in managed care for 50+ years and the late‐life transfer planned to return her to the Pacific Northwest provides an opportunity to illustrate the roles of each stakeholder involved. Also, several other cetacean examples are briefly summarized to illustrate the differing perspectives. Ultimately, compromises may be difficult given the disparate values and mindsets of the stakeholders. It seems that science should be allowed to weigh into this debate rather than allowing media attention, half‐truths, and emotional appeals to govern policy and business models.Keywords
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Cetacean Personhood, Rights, and Flourishing2022
- Nature documentaries as catalysts for change: Mapping out the ‘Blackfish Effect’People and Nature, 2021
- Wild Animals in the City: Considering and Connecting with Animals in Zoos and Aquariums2021
- Large Brains in Small Tanks: Intelligence and Social Complexity as an Ethical Issue for Captive Dolphins and Whales2020
- Looking forward to interacting with their caretakers: dolphins’ anticipatory behaviour indicates motivation to participate in specific eventsApplied Animal Behaviour Science, 2018
- Wild Animals in Entertainment2016
- Ontogeny of memory: An update on 40 years of work on infantile amnesiaBehavioural Brain Research, 2016
- Conservation caring: Measuring the influence of zoo visitors' connection to wildlife on pro-conservation behaviorsZoo Biology, 2013
- Dolphin Shows and Interaction Programs: Benefits for Conservation Education?Zoo Biology, 2012
- Swimming with captive dolphins: current debates and post‐experience dissonanceInternational Journal of Tourism Research, 2007