Earthquakes can increase river discharge while changing the subsurface stores that sustain subsequent low flows. Whether faster postseismic drainage necessarily increases drought vulnerability remains unresolved at catchment scale. We combine a transient storage-drainage model with 1,128 usable catchment-earthquake-sequence comparisons from 335 catchments in New Zealand and Chile. The model yields an exact condition for an initial flow increase to become a later deficit during uninterrupted recession: integrated drainage enhancement must exceed the logarithmic gain in accessible storage. Rapid recovery of drainage pathways can instead accelerate recession without producing a late deficit. An ensemble of 480,766 recharge and drought scenarios extends this distinction to delayed drought onset. Observations do not establish a general persistent loss of catchment memory. For Kaikoura, the best-supported exposure comparison, the strong-minus-light shaking contrast in log recession-rate change is -0.009, with a 95% spatial-block interval of -0.157 to 0.100. Most other sequences lack adequate exposure overlap or spatial replication. These results distinguish an observable recession change from the storage depletion required for earthquake-amplified drought and identify the measurements needed to connect them.