Kellnerius jamacaruensis Santana, Pinheiro, Silva & Saraiva, 2013, a fossil caridean shrimp from the Cretaceous Araripe Basin, has been the subject of a recent redescription by Barros et al. (2025), and we herein provide a methodological and nomenclatural reassessment of Barros et al. (2025). We focus on three main issues: (1) the reinterpretation of a diagnostic groove on the third pleonal somite as a taphonomic artifact, which is contradicted by new high-resolution Scanning Electron Microscope imaging; (2) the application of chemical preparation techniques directly to the holotype; and (3) assertions regarding the nomenclatural status of the species under ICZN provisions and ZooBank registration. New SEM micrographs confirm the presence of the diagnostic groove, supporting the morphological basis for the original species description. We examine issues of taxonomic practice, including specimen conservation, institutional curation, and nomenclatural compliance, highlighting the need for rigorous standards in paleontological taxonomy, careful observation, transparent methodology, and responsible custodianship of scientific heritage.