The Challenges of Implementing Merit-Based Personnel Policies in Latin America: Mexico's Civil Service Reform Experience
- 16 February 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Comparative Policy Analysis: Research and Practice
- Vol. 13 (1) , 51-73
Abstract
Implementation of Merit Based Personnel Policies (MBPP) continues to be a highly problematic endeavour in Latin American countries. According to the literature, this is usually caused by the politico-administrative inheritances that characterize this region, such as patronage, corruption, centralism and the lack of effective accountability mechanisms. By looking at Mexico's recent Civil Service reform process, this article shows that the development of new MBPP has been certainly constrained by some of those factors. However, the article also shows that a number of issues faced during the Mexican reform process can be linked to “simpler” issues of policy design and implementation. The article thus concludes that while “patronage”, “amiguismo”, illegality, and other traditional features of Latin American (and Mexican) administrative systems remain a central impediment for developing well-functioning MBPP, academics and practitioners should probably pay more attention to policy design issues (e.g. policy co-ordination; time and resources availability; institutional framework design), which contribute to better explaining and understanding why MBPP implementation remains such a challenging task in this region.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Civil Service Reform in Latin America: External Referents Versus Own CapacitiesBulletin of Latin American Research, 2008
- The Napoleonic traditionInternational Journal of Public Sector Management, 2008
- Learning from Second‐Hand Experience: Methodology for Extrapolation‐Oriented Case ResearchGovernance, 2007
- Public administration in Latin America: promises, frustrations and new examinationsInternational Review of Administrative Sciences, 2005
- Bureaucracy and Growth: A Cross-National Analysis of the Effects of "Weberian" State Structures on Economic GrowthAmerican Sociological Review, 1999
- Public Personnel Management and Democratization: A View from Three Central American RepublicsPublic Administration Review, 1996
- COMPARATIVE PUBLIC ADMINISTRATION IN BRITAINPublic Administration, 1995
- Reshaping the state: The implications for public administrationWest European Politics, 1994
- A PUBLIC MANAGEMENT FOR ALL SEASONS?Public Administration, 1991
- TOWARD MORE SYSTEMATIC CONSIDERATION OF POLICY DESIGN1Policy Studies Journal, 1987