The Elusive Importance Effect: More Failure for the Jamesian Perspective on the Importance of Importance in Shaping Self‐Esteem
- 15 September 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Personality
- Vol. 76 (5) , 1081-1122
Abstract
Following William James (1890/1963), many leading self‐esteem researchers continue to support the Individual‐importance hypothesis—that the relation between specific facets of self‐concept and global self‐esteem depends on the importance an individual places on each specific facet. However, empirical support for the hypothesis is surprisingly elusive, whether evaluated in terms of an importance‐weighted average model, a generalized multiple regression approach for testing self‐concept‐by‐importance interactions, or idiographic approaches. How can actual empirical support for such an intuitively appealing and widely cited psychological principle be so elusive? Hardy and Moriarty (2006), acknowledging this previous failure of the Individual‐importance hypothesis, claim to have solved the conundrum, demonstrating an innovative idiographic approach that provides clear support for it. However, a critical evaluation of their new approach, coupled with a reanalysis of their data, undermines their claims. Indeed, their data provide compelling support against the Individual‐importance hypothesis, which remains as elusive as ever.Keywords
This publication has 20 references indexed in Scilit:
- Shaping Self-Concept: The Elusive Importance EffectJournal of Personality, 2006
- On the practice of dichotomization of quantitative variables.Psychological Methods, 2002
- Validating the measurement and structure of self-concept: Snapshots of past, present, and future research.American Psychologist, 2002
- Importance Ratings and Specific Components of Physical Self-Concept: Relevance to Predicting Global Components of Self-Concept and ExerciseJournal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1995
- The Importance of Being Important: Theoretical Models of Relations between Specific and Global Components of Physical Self-ConceptJournal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1994
- Relations between global and specific domains of self: The importance of individual importance, certainty, and ideals.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1993
- A multidimensional, hierarchical model of self-concept: Theoretical and empirical justificationEducational Psychology Review, 1990
- Global self-esteem: Its relation to specific facets of self-concept and their importance.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1986
- Influence of individual and group identity salience in the global self-esteem of youth.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1984
- The Perceived Competence Scale for ChildrenChild Development, 1982