Learning to Time (LET) or Scalar Expectancy Theory (SET)? A Critical Test of Two Models of Timing
Authors:
- 1 May 1999
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Psychological Science
- Vol. 10 (3) , 285-290
Abstract
Two theories of timing, scalar expectancy theory (SET) and learning to time (LeT), make substantially different assumptions about what animals learn in temporal tasks. In a test of these assumptions, pigeons learned two discriminations: On Type 1 trials, they learned to choose a red key after a 1-s signal and a green key after a 4-s signal; on Type 2 trials, they learned to choose a blue key after a 4-s signal and a yellow key after a 16-s signal. Then, two psychometric functions were obtained by presenting them with intermediate durations (1 to 4 s and 4 to 16 s). The two functions did not superpose, and most bisection points were not at the geometric mean of the training stimuli (contra SET); for most birds, the function for Type 2 trials was to the left of the function for Type 1 trials (contra LeT). Finally, the birds were exposed to signals ranging from 1 to 16 s and given a choice between novel key combinations (e.g., red vs. blue). The results with the novel key combinations were always closer to LeT's than to SET's predictions. Observations of the birds' behavior also suggest that, more than being a mere expression of an internal clock, behavior constitutes the clock.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Learning the temporal dynamics of behavior.Psychological Review, 1997
- Reinforcement context and pacemaker rate in the behavioral theory of timingLearning & Behavior, 1995
- THE BEHAVIORAL THEORY OF TIMING: REINFORCER RATE DETERMINES PACEMAKER RATEJournal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 1994
- Changing rates of reinforcement perturbs the flow of timeBehavioural Processes, 1993
- Adjusting the pacemakerLearning and Motivation, 1991
- Origins of scalar timingLearning and Motivation, 1991
- A behavioral theory of timing.Psychological Review, 1988
- On the form and location of the Psychometric Bisection Function for timeJournal of Mathematical Psychology, 1981
- Scalar expectancy theory and Weber's law in animal timing.Psychological Review, 1977
- THE DISCRIMINATION OF STIMULUS DURATION BY PIGEONS1Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior, 1968