Value for money tests and accounting treatment in PFI schemes
Author:
- David HealdDHDavid Heald
- 1 August 2003
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Accounting, Auditing & Accountability Journal
- Vol. 16 (3) , 342-371
Abstract
In Private Finance Initiative (PFI) projects, value for money (VFM) tests and accounting treatment are distinct but related issues. VFM analysis should be concerned with total risk, not just with the sharing of risk, which dominates the accounting treatment decision. A framework is developed for logical thinking about what is meant by “best VFM” in the context of PFI projects. This involves consideration of the full set of alternatives, not an artificially diminished subset. The credibility of analytical techniques can be tarnished if they are misused to legitimate a predetermined decision. A reduction in construction risk may be a powerful source of VFM gains under PFI, but, under UK accounting regulation, this should not influence the accounting treatment decision. New complications about how VFM should be interpreted arise directly from the process of public sector fragmentation: affordability to the client is not necessarily the same as VFM for the public sector as a whole. Only public auditors, such as the National Audit Office, can gain access to PFI documentation on the conditions necessary for a comprehensive assessment of both accounting treatment and VFM. However, such studies require the kind of theoretical underpinning provided in this article, as otherwise the findings are likely to be ambiguous and hence vulnerable to rebuttal. In particular, VFM judgements must make explicit the basis of comparison on which they rest.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Underestimating Costs in Public Works Projects:Error or Lie?Journal of the American Planning Association, 2002
- Public–private partnerships: lessons from the British approachEconomic Systems, 2002
- Appraising and Evaluating PFI for NHS HospitalsFinancial Accountability & Management, 2001
- Accounting for the Private Finance Initiative in the United Kingdom National Health ServiceFinancial Accountability & Management, 1999
- The Private Finance Initiative in the National Health Service: An Unhealthy Development in New Public Management?Financial Accountability & Management, 1999
- The Private Finance Initiative: Clarification of a Future Research AgendaFinancial Accountability & Management, 1999
- Twenty-one sources of error and bias in transport project appraisalTransport Policy, 1998
- Privately Financed Capital in Public ServicesThe Manchester School, 1997
- Exploring Policy Analysis1980
- ‘Values’ in the Policy ProcessPolicy & Politics, 1977