Implementation Fidelity: The Disconnect Between Theory and Practice
Open Access
- 24 January 2025
- journal article
- Published by The Evaluation Center at Western Michigan University in Journal of Multidisciplinary Evaluation
- Vol. 21 (49) , 23-37
Abstract
The current paper combines a conceptual analysis of major reviews of implementation fidelity studies (e.g., Dane & Schneider, 1998; Mowbray et al., 2003; O’Donnell, 2008) with reflections on fidelity measurement practice in field evaluations. It claims that practice is impoverished by the failure to recognize the existence of competing conceptualizations of fidelity, rooted in different theoretical perspectives. Different evaluation contexts may be better matched to one or the other of these perspectives. Confusion about how fidelity should be defined in a given funding program or evaluation prevents evaluators from instituting a maximally useful fidelity measurement program. Difficulties inherent to creating high-quality fidelity measures contribute to the problem. The causes and consequences of this disconnect between fidelity theory and fidelity practice are discussed herein. Preliminary suggestions for solutions are advanced.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- How do we deepen our story reservoir by designing, developing, and writing instructional cases for teaching evaluation?New Directions for Evaluation, 2021
- Why so many “rigorous” evaluations fail to identify unintended consequences of development programs: How mixed methods can contributeEvaluation and Program Planning, 2016
- Do we really care about unintended outcomes? An analysis of evaluation theory and practiceEvaluation and Program Planning, 2016
- A Procedure for Assessing Intervention Fidelity in Experiments Testing Educational and Behavioral InterventionsThe Journal of Behavioral Health Services & Research, 2012
- What is successful adaptation of lesson study in the US?Journal of Educational Change, 2008
- Treatment Strength and Integrity: Models and Methods.2006
- PROGRAM INTEGRITY IN PRIMARY AND EARLY SECONDARY PREVENTION: ARE IMPLEMENTATION EFFECTS OUT OF CONTROL?Clinical Psychology Review, 1998
- Optimizing validity in program research: An elaboration of Chen and Rossi's theory-driven approachEvaluation and Program Planning, 1989
- The functions of program theoryNew Directions for Program Evaluation, 1987
- Evaluation: The state of the art and the sorry state of the scienceNew Directions for Program Evaluation, 1985