The Effect of Question Framing and Response Options on the Relationship between Racial Attitudes and Beliefs about Genes as Causes of Behavior
Authors:
- Eleanor SingerESEleanor Singer
- Mick P. CouperMCMick P. Couper
- Trivellore E. RaghunathanTRTrivellore E. Raghunathan
- Toni C. AntonucciTAToni C. Antonucci
- Margit BurmeisterMBMargit Burmeister
- John Van HoewykJHJohn Van Hoewyk
- 31 March 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Public Opinion Quarterly
- Vol. 74 (3) , 460-476
Abstract
Prior research suggests that the attribution of individual and group differences to genetic causes is correlated with prejudiced attitudes toward minority groups. Our study suggests that these findings may be due to the wording of the questions and to the choice of response options. Using a series of vignettes in an online survey, we find a relationship between racial attitudes and genetic attributions when respondents are asked to make causal attributions of differences between racial groups. However, when they are asked to make causal attributions for characteristics shown by individuals, no such relationship is found. The response scale used appears to make less, if any, difference in the results. These findings indicate that the way questions about genetic causation of behavior are framed makes a significant contribution to the answers obtained because it significantly changes the meaning of the questions. We argue that such framing needs to be carefully attended to, not only in posing research questions but also in discourse about genetics more generally.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Beliefs about Genes and Environment as Determinants of Behavioral CharacteristicsInternational Journal of Public Opinion Research, 2007
- Genetic Variant BDNF (Val66Met) Polymorphism Alters Anxiety-Related BehaviorScience, 2006
- Do the print media "hype" genetic research? A comparison of newspaper stories and peer-reviewed research papersCanadian Medical Association Journal, 2004
- A Historical Note on Whites' Beliefs about Racial InequalityAmerican Sociological Review, 1999
- Authoritarianism in the General Population: The Education Interaction HypothesisSocial Psychology Quarterly, 1992
- Trends in Whites' Explanations of the Black-White Gap in Socioeconomic Status, 1977-1989American Sociological Review, 1990
- The Impact of Home Ownership On Whites' Racial AttitudesAmerican Politics Quarterly, 1990
- Category‐breadth and social‐desirability values for 573 personality termsEuropean Journal of Personality, 1987
- Ethnic stereotypes: Norms on 208 words typically used in their assessment.Canadian Journal of Psychology / Revue canadienne de psychologie, 1972
- Attitudes vs. Actions Versus Attitudes vs. AttitudesPublic Opinion Quarterly, 1972