Need for an “Integrated Safety Assessment” of GMOs, Linking Food Safety and Environmental Considerations
- 6 April 2006
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry
- Vol. 54 (9) , 3173-3180
Abstract
Evidence for substantial environmental influences on health and food safety comes from work with environmental health indicators which show that agroenvironmental practices have direct and indirect effects on human health, concluding that “the quality of the environment influences the quality and safety of foods” [Fennema, O. Environ. Health Perspect.1990, 86, 229−232). In the field of genetically modified organisms (GMOs), Codex principles have been established for the assessment of GM food safety and the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety outlines international principles for an environmental assessment of living modified organisms. Both concepts also contain starting points for an assessment of health/food safety effects of GMOs in cases when the environment is involved in the chain of events that could lead to hazards. The environment can act as a route of unintentional entry of GMOs into the food supply, such as in the case of gene flow via pollen or seeds from GM cropss, but the environment can also be involved in changes of GMO-induced agricultural practices with relevance for health/food safety. Examples for this include potential regional changes of pesticide uses and reduction in pesticide poisonings resulting from the use of Bt crops or influences on immune responses via cross-reactivity. Clearly, modern methods of biotechnology in breeding are involved in the reasons behind the rapid reduction of local varieties in agrodiversity, which constitute an identified hazard for food safety and food security. The health/food safety assessment of GM foods in cases when the environment is involved needs to be informed by data from environmental assessment. Such data might be especially important for hazard identification and exposure assessment. International organizations working in these areas will very likely be needed to initiate and enable cooperation between those institutions responsible for the different assessments, as well as for exchange and analysis of information. An integrated assessment might help to focus and save capacities in highly technical areas such as molecular characterization or profiling, which are often necessary for both assessments. In the area of establishing international standards for traded foods, such as for the newly created Standards in Trade and Development Facility (STDF), an integrated assessment might help in the consideration of important environmental aspects involved in health and food safety. Furthermore, an established integrated view on GMOs may create greater consumer confidence in the technology. Keywords: GMO; GM food; LMO; food safety; environmental safety; CODEX; Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety; integrated safety assessmentKeywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Safe and acceptable strategies for producing foreign molecules in plantsCurrent Opinion in Plant Biology, 2004
- On risk and plant-based biopharmaceuticalsTrends in Biotechnology, 2004
- Codex guidelines for GM foods include the analysis of unintended effectsNature Biotechnology, 2003
- Improved evaluation of potential allergens in GM foodTrends in Biotechnology, 2003
- Making 'safety first' a reality for biotechnology productsNature Biotechnology, 2003
- Transgenic crops—why gene flow mattersNature Biotechnology, 2002
- Rethinking substantial equivalenceNature Biotechnology, 2002
- When Transgenes Wander, Should We Worry?Plant Physiology, 2001
- Monitoring and Labeling for Genetically Modified ProductsScience, 2000
- Influence of food-environment interactions on health in the twenty-first century.Environmental Health Perspectives, 1990