Logistic, ethical, and political dimensions of stepped wedge trials: critical review and case studies
Authors:
- Audrey ProstAPAudrey Prost
- Ariella BinikABAriella Binik
- Ibrahim AbubakarIAIbrahim Abubakar
- Anjana RoyARAnjana Roy
- Manuela De AllegriManuela De Allegri
- Christelle MouchouxCMChristelle Mouchoux
- Tobias DreischulteTDTobias Dreischulte
- Helen AylesHAHelen Ayles
- James J. LewisJLJames J. Lewis
- David OsrinDODavid Osrin
Open Access
- 17 August 2015
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Springer Nature in Trials
- Vol. 16 (1) , 1-11
Abstract
Three arguments are usually invoked in favour of stepped wedge cluster randomised controlled trials: the logistic convenience of implementing an intervention in phases, the ethical benefit of providing the intervention to all clusters, and the potential to enhance the social acceptability of cluster randomised controlled trials. Are these alleged benefits real? We explored the logistic, ethical, and political dimensions of stepped wedge trials using case studies of six recent evaluations. We identified completed or ongoing stepped wedge evaluations using two systematic reviews. We then purposively selected six with a focus on public health in high, middle, and low-income settings. We interviewed their authors about the logistic, ethical, and social issues faced by their teams. Two authors reviewed interview transcripts, identified emerging issues through qualitative thematic analysis, reflected upon them in the context of the literature, and invited all participants to co-author the manuscript. Our analysis raises three main points. First, the phased implementation of interventions can alleviate problems linked to simultaneous roll-out, but also brings new challenges. Issues to consider include the feasibility of organising intervention activities according to a randomised sequence, estimating time lags in implementation and effects, and accommodating policy changes during the trial period. Second, stepped wedge trials, like parallel cluster trials, require equipoise: without it, randomising participants to a control condition, even for a short time, remains problematic. In stepped wedge trials, equipoise is likely to lie in the degree of effect, effectiveness in a specific operational milieu, and the balance of benefit and harm, including the social value of better evaluation. Third, the strongest arguments for a stepped wedge design are logistic and political rather than ethical. The design is advantageous when simultaneous roll-out is impractical and when it increases the acceptability of using counterfactuals. The logistic convenience of phased implementation is context-dependent, and may be vitiated by the additional requirements of phasing. The potential for stepped wedge trials to enhance the social acceptability of cluster randomised trials is real, but their ethical legitimacy still rests on demonstrating equipoise and its configuration for each research question and setting.Keywords
This publication has 64 references indexed in Scilit:
- The impact of an exercise physiologist coordinated resistance exercise program on the physical function of people receiving hemodialysis: a stepped wedge randomised control studyBMC Nephrology, 2013
- The effect of training doctors in communication skills on women’s satisfaction with doctor–woman relationship during labour and delivery: a stepped wedge cluster randomised trial in DamascusBMJ Open, 2013
- Use of the stepped wedge design cannot be recommended: A critical appraisal and comparison with the classic cluster randomized controlled trial designJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2012
- The longitudinal prevalence of MRSA in care home residents and the effectiveness of improving infection prevention knowledge and practice on colonisation using a stepped wedge study designBMJ Open, 2012
- Systematic review of stepped wedge cluster randomized trials shows that design is particularly used to evaluate interventions during routine implementationJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 2011
- The case study approachBMC Medical Research Methodology, 2011
- Act In case of Depression: The evaluation of a care program to improve the detection and treatment of depression in nursing homes. Study ProtocolBMC Psychiatry, 2011
- Impact of a multifaceted program to prevent postoperative delirium in the elderly: the CONFUCIUS stepped wedge protocolBMC Geriatrics, 2011
- Developing and evaluating complex interventions: the new Medical Research Council guidanceBMJ, 2008
- Design and analysis of stepped wedge cluster randomized trialsContemporary Clinical Trials, 2007