Getting the balance right
- 20 May 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Engineering, Construction and Architectural Management
- Vol. 26 (4) , 599-617
Abstract
Purpose: In Australia, national harmonisation of occupational health and safety (OHS) regulation was pursued through the development of model Work Health and Safety legislation. The model Work Health and Safety Regulations specify that construction works above a threshold cost of AU$250,000 are deemed to be construction projects requiring the appointment of a principal contractor with duties relating to OHS planning and coordination. The purpose of this paper is to explore the effectiveness of the monetary threshold as a suitable trigger for specific OHS planning and coordination duties.Design/methodology/approach: Interviews were conducted with 46 Australian construction industry stakeholders, including union representatives, employer groups, construction firm representatives and regulators, as well as four international construction OHS experts, to explore perceptions about the effectiveness of the monetary threshold. Two construction scenarios were also modelled to test for variability in operation of the threshold by geographical location of works and design conditions.Findings: The monetary threshold was perceived to be subject to two forms of capture problem, reflecting inadvertent capture of low risk works or failure to capture high risk works. Organisations were also reported to deliberately split contracts to avoid capture by the threshold. The cost-estimate modelling revealed inequalities and variation in the operation of the monetary threshold by geographic location and design specification.Practical implications: The analysis suggests that limitations inherent in the use of a monetary threshold to trigger duties relating to OHS planning and coordination in construction works. Opportunities to use more sophisticated risk-based mechanisms are considered.Originality/value: The study explores a fundamental challenge of risk-based OHS regulation, i.e., how to ensure that workers’ health and safety are adequately protected without creating an unnecessarily high regulatory burden. The research provides evidence that using a monetary value as a proxy measure for OHS risk in construction projects may be problematic.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Myths and Realities of Deterrence in Workplace Safety RegulationThe British Journal of Criminology, 2013
- The Long and Winding Road to OHS HarmonisationLabour History, 2013
- Applying indicators, threshold values and proxies in environmental legislation: A case study for Dutch dairy farmingEnvironmental Science & Policy, 2011
- Organizational Trust and the Limits of Management-Based RegulationLaw & Society Review, 2009
- The Dangers of Hanging Baskets: ‘Regulatory Myths’ and Media Representations of Health and Safety RegulationJournal of Law and Society, 2009
- The risks of risk-based regulation: Insights from the environmental policy domainEnvironment International, 2006
- A theory of risk colonization: The spiralling regulatory logics of societal and institutional riskEconomy and Society, 2006
- Enforced Self‐Regulation, Prescription, and Conceptions of Compliance within Small Businesses: The Impact of Enforcement*Law & Policy, 2005
- Fatalities in Trenching Operations—Analysis Using Models of Accident CausationJournal of Construction Engineering and Management, 2004
- Management-Based Regulation: Prescribing Private Management to Achieve Public GoalsLaw & Society Review, 2003