Contextualizing the meaning of public management reforms: a comparison of the Netherlands and South Korea
Authors:
- 1 June 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Review of Administrative Sciences
- Vol. 76 (2) , 367-386
Abstract
Previous literature has demonstrated that the apparent global convergence between public management reforms is misleading because there are major differences in how a global paradigm of reform is implemented. This is not only a question of implementation, but also of interpretation. Even when reforms are similar with respect to the administrative measures that are implemented, they can have significantly different political and cultural meanings, depending on the broader state—society relations within which they are embedded. A cross-national analysis of reforms must therefore take sufficient account of the historical development of the position of the state and of state—civil society relations. To demonstrate the point, the article compares public management reforms in the Netherlands and South Korea. Points for practitioners Although cross-national comparison of public management reforms can be a source of inspiration, it is crucial to keep in mind that similar reforms can have different meanings depending on the national context and thus can result in different policies, programmes, and institutions. For practitioners in public management and administration, this implies that, before importing ‘good’ practices from elsewhere, it is imperative to assess how those practices were part of broader historical developments in the country of origin and to what extent the conditions within the country of destination are different.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- Reining in the Bureaucrats: Democratic Transition and Administrative Procedural Reform in KoreaGovernance, 2007
- FRAGMENTED BUT FORCEFUL: DUTCH ADMINISTRATIVE SCIENCES AND THEIR INSTITUTIONAL EVOLUTIONPublic Administration, 2006
- Dynamics of the Welfare Mix in the Republic of Korea: An Expenditure Study Between 1990 and 2001International Social Security Review, 2005
- Griffins or Chameleons? Hybridity as a Permanent and Inevitable Characteristic of the Third SectorInternational Journal of Public Administration, 2005
- Reform Styles of Political and Administrative Elites in Majoritarian and Consensus Democracies: Public Management Reforms in New Zealand and the NetherlandsPublic Administration, 2004
- Budgetary and Financial Management Reforms in Korea: Financial Crisis, New Public Management, and Fiscal AdministrationInternational Review of Administrative Sciences, 2004
- Convergence: The Useful Myth?Public Administration, 2001
- Comparative Public Administration: From Failed Universal Theory to Raw Empiricism—a Frank Analysis and Guidelines Towards a Realistic PerspectiveInternational Review of Administrative Sciences, 2000
- Public Administration in a Global Context: Bridging the Gaps of Theory and Practice between Western and Non-Western NationsPublic Administration Review, 1998
- A PUBLIC MANAGEMENT FOR ALL SEASONS?Public Administration, 1991