Rights in Immigration: The Veil as a Test Case
Author:
- Gila StoplerGSGila Stopler
- 1 January 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Israel Law Review
- Vol. 43 (1) , 183-217
Abstract
Immigration often involves the migration of people of specific cultural and religious background to countries in which the predominant cultural and religious background is quite different. This may result in attempts by receiving countries to restrict the new immigrants ‘cultural and religious practices. The Article uses the debate surrounding the wearing of the veil in Europe as a test case for the way in which recognition rights may be affected by the process of immigration. First, the Article maintains that the balance of rights and interests involved in conflicts over immigrants’ rights changes along the process of immigration, and divides this process into three stages—the entry application, the application for citizenship, and the life as an immigrant in the receiving country. Subsequently, it lays out the conflicting rights and interests involved in the veil controversy—the conflict between immigrant and local cultures; the conflict between immigrants’ religious liberty and state interests such as maintaining religious neutrality/laïcité, and protecting from the perceived threat of radical political Islam; the conflicting claims regarding the effects of veiling on women's equality. Finally, the Article analyzes each of these conflicts along the three stages of immigration and offers an assessment of the validity of the conflicting claims surrounding the veil in Europe on the basis of this analysis, claiming that the restrictions on wearing the veil in the public sphere are not justified, but that a much narrower restriction pertaining to some instances of the wearing of the full face burqa can be justified.Keywords
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Immigrants, Nations, and Citizenship*Journal of Political Philosophy, 2008
- The Culture of CitizenshipTheoretical Inquiries in Law, 2007
- Contextualizing Multiculturalism: A Three Dimensional Examination of Multicultural ClaimsThe Law & Ethics of Human Rights, 2007
- Germany: Freedom of conscience in public schoolsInternational Journal of Constitutional Law, 2005
- Dissonances within LaïcitéConstellations, 2004
- Lifting the VeilFrench Politics, Culture & Society, 2004
- Feminist Ethics, Autonomy and the Politics of MulticulturalismFeminist Theory, 2003
- Nationalism and immigration2003
- The Challenge of Pluralism: Church and State in Five DemocraciesJournal for the Scientific Study of Religion, 1999
- Political LiberalismHarvard Law Review, 1994