Online reviews help consumers evaluate products they cannot physically inspect before purchase. Sensory language, i.e., words engaging the five senses (sound, touch, vision, smell, and taste), can provide valuable information about otherwise inaccessible product experiences and thus can be expected to make reviews more helpful. However, we show that this view is incomplete: the effect of sensory language is both sense-specific and contingent on the textual, visual, and prior-review context. Drawing on the accessibility-diagnosticity framework and analyzing approximately 15 million Amazon reviews, we find that sensory language increases helpful votes, especially in reviews with a stronger first-person perspective and more positive valence. However, the impact of sensory language on helpful votes weakens when prior reviews already provide more sensory information and even turns negative when the review includes images (which compete with review text). Among the senses, using sound words is considered especially helpful. Based on these findings, we recommend that platforms prioritize sensory-rich reviews when they convey personal or positive product experiences and when comparable sensory information is otherwise scarce. Review images are found to function like a doubleedged sword: while they lift helpful votes by themselves, they strongly diminish the effect of sensory language on review helpfulness.