Student resistance in the classroom—Functional‐instrumentalist, critical‐emancipatory and critical‐functional conceptualisations
- 12 July 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Higher Education Quarterly
- Vol. 73 (4) , 521-538
Abstract
The paper provides a systemic literature review and a typology of texts that discuss student resistance in the classroom in Higher Education. Analysing 134 empirical and conceptual studies published between 1988 and 2018 for how student resistance is conceptualised, this review identifies three approaches: functional‐instrumentalist, critical‐emancipatory and critical‐functional. Presenting the three approaches in more depth, the article points to the main tenets, like supposed reasons for and suggested ways of handling student resistance. In the final part of the analysis, the paper discusses the typology in light of the current institutional background of Higher Education, including the managerial university and ambivalences of critical education. Finally, the article offers future research directions.Keywords
This publication has 129 references indexed in Scilit:
- Multiple-Choice Exams: An Obstacle for Higher-Level Thinking in Introductory Science ClassesCBE—Life Sciences Education, 2012
- Student Identity, Disengagement, and LearningAcademy of Management Learning & Education, 2012
- Enhancing Interdisciplinary, Mathematics, and Physical Science in an Undergraduate Life Science Program through Physical ChemistryCBE—Life Sciences Education, 2009
- Deconstructing Power, Privilege, and Silence in the ClassroomRadical History Review, 2008
- Enhancing Self‐Directed Learning through Educational Technology: When Students Resist the ChangeInnovations in Education and Training International, 1999
- An attributional analysis of college students' resistance decisionsCommunication Education, 1991
- College teacher misbehaviors: What students don't like about what teachers say and doCommunication Quarterly, 1991
- Compliance‐resistance in the college classroomCommunication Education, 1989
- Experienced and prospective teachers' selections of compliance‐gaining messages for “common” student misbehaviorsCommunication Education, 1988
- Effects of teacher immediacy and strategy type on college student resistance to on‐task demandsCommunication Education, 1988