The Scientific Justification for a U.S. Domestic High-Performance Reactor-Based Research Facility

Authors:

Abstract
The Basic Energy Science Advisory Committee (BESAC) was charged with forming a subcommittee to assess the scientific justification for a U.S. domestic high-performance reactor-based research facility (implicitly low-enriched uranium), taking into account current international plans and existing domestic facility infrastructure, in order to continue providing the U.S scientific community with leading neutron capabilities in support of DOE's missions in science, energy, environment, and national security. The subcommittee held a series of meetings from August 19, 2019 to April 24, 2020, which included DOE senior officials, leaders of existing national and international neutron facilities (SNS, HFIR, NIST, ILL, FRM-II), chairs of the NAS and POPA HEU-LEU committees, outside experts on virtually all of the different important areas of science, technology, and industry where high flux nuclear reactor facilities make important contributions, and tours of existing neutron facilities (SNS, HFIR, NIST, BR2 reactor, and the planned Jules Horowitz Reactor). This July 2020 report describes scientific use cases, brief summaries of existing and planned neutron facilities in the US and Europe, a comprehensive review of HFIR, a comprehensive discussion of the current state of progress on HEU-LEU conversion, user information from NIST and ORNL, and three recommendations to DOE for moving forward.