A Comparison of Biomarker Based Incidence Estimators
Open Access
- 7 October 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Public Library of Science (PLoS) in PLOS ONE
- Vol. 4 (10) , e7368
Abstract
Cross-sectional surveys utilizing biomarkers that test for recent infection provide a convenient and cost effective way to estimate HIV incidence. In particular, the BED assay has been developed for this purpose. Controversy surrounding the way in which false positive results from the biomarker should be handled has lead to a number of different estimators that account for imperfect specificity. We compare the estimators proposed by McDougal et al., Hargrove et al. and McWalter & Welte. The three estimators are analyzed and compared. An identity showing a relationship between the calibration parameters in the McDougal methodology is shown. When the three estimators are tested under a steady state epidemic, which includes individuals who fail to progress on the biomarker, only the McWalter/Welte method recovers an unbiased result. Our analysis shows that the McDougal estimator can be reduced to a formula that only requires calibration of a mean window period and a long-term specificity. This allows simpler calibration techniques to be used and shows that all three estimators can be expressed using the same set of parameters. The McWalter/Welte method is applicable under the least restrictive assumptions and is the least prone to bias of the methods reviewed.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- On the Use of Adjusted Cross-Sectional Estimators of HIV IncidenceJAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes, 2009
- Relating recent infection prevalence to incidence with a sub-population of assay non-progressorsJournal of Mathematical Biology, 2009
- Should biomarker estimates of HIV incidence be adjusted?AIDS, 2009
- Improved HIV-1 incidence estimates using the BED capture enzyme immunoassayAIDS, 2008
- Comparison of HIV Type 1 Incidence Observed during Longitudinal Follow-Up with Incidence Estimated by Cross-Sectional Analysis Using the BED Capture Enzyme ImmunoassayAIDS Research and Human Retroviruses, 2006
- Performance Characteristics of the Immunoglobulin G-Capture BED-Enzyme Immunoassay, an Assay To Detect Recent Human Immunodeficiency Virus Type 1 SeroconversionJournal of Clinical Microbiology, 2004
- HIV Type 1 Incidence Estimates by Detection of Recent Infection from a Cross-Sectional Sampling of Injection Drug Users in Bangkok: Use of the IgG Capture BED Enzyme ImmunoassayAIDS Research and Human Retroviruses, 2003
- Quantitative Detection of Increasing HIV Type 1 Antibodies after Seroconversion: A Simple Assay for Detecting Recent HIV Infection and Estimating IncidenceAIDS Research and Human Retroviruses, 2002
- New Testing Strategy to Detect Early HIV-1 Infection for Use in Incidence Estimates and for Clinical and Prevention PurposesJAMA, 1998
- Estimation of Current Human Immunodeficiency Virus Incidence Rates from a Cross-Sectional Survey Using Early Diagnostic TestsAmerican Journal of Epidemiology, 1995