If you like it, does it matter if it's real?
- 8 February 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Philosophical Psychology
- Vol. 23 (1) , 43-57
Abstract
Most people's intuitive reaction after considering Nozick's experience machine thought-experiment seems to be just like his: we feel very little inclination to plug in to a virtual reality machine capable of providing us with pleasurable experiences. Many philosophers take this empirical fact as sufficient reason to believe that, more than pleasurable experiences, people care about “living in contact with reality.” Such claim, however, assumes that people's reaction to the experience machine thought-experiment is due to the fact that they value reality over virtual experiences—an assumption that has seldom (if ever) been questioned. This paper challenges that very assumption. I report some experimental evidence suggesting that the intuition elicited by the thought-experiment may be explainable by the fact that people are averse to abandon the life they have been experiencing so far, regardless of whether such life is virtual or real. I use then an explanatory model, derived from what behavioral economists and psychologists call the status quo bias, to make sense of these results. Finally, I argue that since this explanation also accounts for people's reaction toward Nozick's thought-experiment, it would be wrong to take such intuition as evidence that people value being in touch with reality.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Reversal Test: Eliminating Status Quo Bias in Applied EthicsEthics, 2006
- Happiness theories of the good lifeJournal of Happiness Studies, 2006
- Varieties of HedonismJournal of Social Philosophy, 2002
- In Defense of HappinessSocial Theory and Practice, 2000
- The Experience Machine and Mental State Theories of Well-beingThe Journal of Value Inquiry, 1999
- Philosophical Intuitions and Psychological TheoryEthics, 1998
- Anomalies: The Endowment Effect, Loss Aversion, and Status Quo BiasJournal of Economic Perspectives, 1991
- Status quo bias in decision makingJournal of Risk and Uncertainty, 1988
- Willingness to Pay and Compensation Demanded: Experimental Evidence of an Unexpected Disparity in Measures of ValueThe Quarterly Journal of Economics, 1984
- Choices, values, and frames.American Psychologist, 1984