Evaluating Design Fiction
Authors:
Open Access
- 3 July 2020
- conference paper
- Published by Association for Computing Machinery (ACM)
- p. 1901-1913
Abstract
Design fiction has become so widely adopted that it regularly appears in contexts ranging from CEO speeches to dedicated tracks at academic conferences. However, evaluating this kind of work is difficult; it is not clear what good or bad design fiction is or what the judgment criteria should be. In this paper we assert that design fiction is a heterogeneous set of methods, and practices, able to produce a diversity of scholarly and design contributions. We argue locating these diverse practices under the single header of "design fiction" has resulted in epistemological confusion over the appropriate method of evaluation. We identify different traditions within the HCI literature-critical design; narratology and literary theory; studio-based design "crits"; user studies; scenarios and persona development; and thought experiments-to articulate a typology of evaluative frames. There is often a mismatch between the standards to which design fiction is held and the knowledge that speculative methods seek to produce. We argue that evaluating a given instance of design fiction requires us to properly select the right epistemological tool for the job.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Science Foundation (IIS-1844901)
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- The hitchhiker’s guide to ubicomp: using techniques from literary and critical theory to reframe scientific agendasPersonal and Ubiquitous Computing, 2013
- Speculative design: crafting the speculationDigital Creativity, 2013
- COVER STORYDesign fictionInteractions, 2009
- The ImaginaryAnthropological Theory, 2006
- The aesthetic turn: unravelling recent aesthetic approaches to human-computer interactionDigital Creativity, 2005
- Thought Experiments Rethought—and ReperceivedPhilosophy of Science, 2004
- Pastiche scenariosInteractions, 2004
- The Narrative Construction of RealityCritical Inquiry, 1991
- Minds, brains, and programsBehavioral and Brain Sciences, 1980
- Meaning and ReferenceThe Journal of Philosophy, 1973