What actually is the Münch hypothesis? A short history of assimilate transport by mass flow
- 11 May 2017
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Integrative Plant Biology
- Vol. 59 (5) , 292-310
Abstract
In the 1920s, the German forestry scientist Ernst Münch postulated that photo‐assimilate transport is a mass flow driven by osmotically induced pressure gradients between source organs (high turgor) and sink organs (lower turgor). Two crucial components of Münch's hypothesis, the translocation by mass flow from sources to sinks and the osmotic mechanism of pressure flow, were established notions at the time, but had been developed by two institutionally separated groups of scholars. A conceptual separation of whole‐plant biology from cellular physiology had followed the institutional separation of forestry science from botany in German‐speaking central Europe during the so‐called Humboldtian reforms, and was reinforced by the delayed institutionalization of plant physiology as an academic discipline. Münch did not invent a novel concept, but accomplished an integration of the organism‐focused and the cell‐focused research traditions, reducing the polarization that had evolved when research universities emerged in central Europe. Post‐Münch debates about the validity of his hypothesis focused increasingly on the suitability of available research methodologies, especially the electron microscope and the proper interpretation of the results it produced. The present work reconstructs the influence of the dynamic scientific and non‐scientific context on the history of the Münch hypothesis.Keywords
This publication has 65 references indexed in Scilit:
- Phloem Ultrastructure and Pressure Flow: Sieve-Element-Occlusion-Related Agglomerations Do Not Affect TranslocationThe Plant Cell, 2011
- GFP Tagging of Sieve Element Occlusion (SEO) Proteins Results in Green Fluorescent ForisomesPlant and Cell Physiology, 2008
- Metabolic inhibitors induce symplastic movement of solutes from the transport phloem ofArabidopsisrootsJournal of Experimental Botany, 1997
- Living sieve cells of conifers as visualized by confocal, laser-scanning fluorescence microscopyProtoplasma, 1992
- TRANSLOCATION OF SOLUTES IN FUNGIBiological Reviews, 1987
- The electroosmotic theory of phloem transport: a final restatementPlant, Cell & Environment, 1979
- Sieve-plate pores, open or occluded? A critical reviewPlant, Cell & Environment, 1978
- Globules and Coagula: Concepts of Tissue Formation in the Early Nineteenth CenturyJournal of the History of Medicine and Allied Sciences, 1973
- THE BIO-ELECTRIC POTENTIALS OF PLANTS AND THEIR FUNCTIONAL SIGNIFICANCE: I. AN ELECTROKINETIC THEORY OF TRANSPORTCanadian Journal of Botany, 1957
- Gibt es eine Verzugsstrafe?Juristische Rundschau, 1948