Measurement, Accountability, and Humaneness
Author:
- 16 July 1971
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Measurement and Evaluation in Guidance
- Vol. 4 (2) , 90-98
Abstract
Personnel in innovative educational programs, especially those using federal funds, have had to face an increasing challenge to be accountable. Part of this challenge is probably caused by the seeming lack of difference among programs as measured by standardized achievement tests. Questions have been raised regarding the ability of norm-based achievement tests to differentiate among outcomes of two or more academic programs. For example, some advocates of criterion-based tests feel that the latter are more suitable in differentiating among program outcomes. Both norm and criterion-based measurement are examined in this article in regard to those characteristics that may affect their ability to measure outcomes of competing programs. One criticism involves the seeming inability of norm-based achievement tests to rank students differently from the way group intelligence tests rank them. Another involves the curriculum-specific, or idiosyncratic nature of criterion-based tests, and to some extent norm-based tests. Those characteristics of both types of tests that present difficulties regarding the measurement of differences among programs do not necessarily preclude their potential usefulness within any one program. In view of the above difficulties, it is suggested that funders revise the manner in which accountability is determined regarding both program superiority and the way in which special school programs are evaluated. In any alternative mode of showing accountability, preoccupation with dollars and amount learned should not take precedence over humaneness in the classroom.Keywords
This publication has 2 references indexed in Scilit:
- IMPLICATIONS OF CRITERION‐REFERENCED MEASUREMENT1,2Journal of Educational Measurement, 1969
- Instructional technology and the measurement of learing outcomes: Some questions.American Psychologist, 1963