Upper Jurassic Smackover Platform Dolomitization, Northwestern Gulf of Mexico

Authors:

Abstract
The Upper Jurassic Smackover Formation of eastern Texas and western Arkansas exhibits a classic example of platform dolomitization. The close stratigraphic proximity of dolomitized Smackover strata, immediately below thick Buckner evaporites, combined with common vertical dolomitization gradients increasing toward the formational contact, strongly suggests an evaporative-reflux origin for the dolomite. The geologic setting of the Buckner, interpreted as a long-lived evaporative lagoon, supports this model. Chemical composition of the dolomite, however, such as depleted 18O (average -2.7‰), low Sr and Na content (average 40 and 157 ppm, respectively) suggest meteoric-water influences. Elevated 87Sr, and high Fe and Mn compositions of some platform interior dolomites indicate that extremely large volumes of meteoric water, passing first through intercalated siliciclastics, were involved. Two models generally satisify the necessity for involvement of both refluxed evaporative waters and meteoric waters: (1) an evaporative reflux-meteoric water-mixing model, where refluxing brines from the overlying Buckner lagoon mix with an active meteoric-water system in the upper Smackover, providing the Mg for dolomitization; (2) a recrystallization model, where the upper Smackover was initially dolomitized by reflux of evaporative brines from the overlying Buckner lagoon and subsequently recrystallized in a major meteoric-water system. The authors do not unanimously support either model. Chowdhury and Chan prefer the recrystallization model, because trace-element and Sr isotope data seem to preclude involvement of marine waters during final dolomitization. Moore favors the evaporative reflux-meteoric mixing model, because it is the simplest model that satisfies most constraints, the Sr isotope data supporting recrystallization is limited, and because there is no clear petrographic evidence for recrystallization.