Subduction zone magnetic anomalies have previously been used to infer their thermal structure assuming a uniformly serpentinised mantle carries a homogeneous, isotropic magnetisation parallel to the present-day magnetic field. However, seismic tomography, geological observations and numerical modelling provide increasing evidence for a non-uniformly serpentinised and deformed mantle wedge that may carry heterogeneous, anisotropic magnetisation. In this study, we uncover a connection between the degree of serpentinisation and rock magnetic properties in variably serpentinised, sheared mantle wedge samples the Santa Catalina Island/Pimu’nga in California, USA. Heavily serpentinised samples host anisotropic, petrofabric-parallel magnetisation, whereas partially serpentinised samples host predominantly isotropic, induced magnetisation parallel to the Earth’s magnetic field. We assume these sheared, heavily serpentinised samples are analogous to seismically imaged anisotropic, heavily serpentinised mantle wedge just above the megathrust. We propose that a layer of subduction-aligned magnetisation in heavily serpentinised rock occurs at the base of the mantle wedge, above which partially serpentinised rock hosts induced magnetisation parallel to the present-day magnetic field. This proposal precludes the direct connection between subduction zone magnetic anomalies and thermal structure (i.e., the use of Curie point depths), though the effect of subduction-parallel magnetisation may be corrected for.