An Alternative to Desktop GIS? Evaluating the Cartographic and Analytical Capabilities of WebGIS Platforms for Teaching
Authors:
- 2 April 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Cartographic Journal
- Vol. 57 (2) , 175-186
Abstract
The increasing prevalence of (open) geospatial data has amplified the demand for online tools to input, manage, and analyse data and generate cartographic outputs. WebGIS platforms are responding to this demand by delivering cost-effective, relatively easy to use compared to desktop GIS software, and increasingly sophisticated tools. The continued advancement of webGIS platforms highlights the necessary, but tricky, integration of these platforms into university curriculum. In this paper, we develop an evaluation framework for users to assess, compare, and benchmark the cartographic capabilities of four webGIS platforms–ArcGIS Online, Carto, Mapbox, and GIS Cloud–against standard GIS functionality. The webGIS platforms studied offer advanced data management and some spatial analysis capabilities, but in contrast, they have limited cartographic capabilities for creating static maps. Recognizing that platforms change, and change often, this study serves to benchmark the capabilities of webGIS platforms, while reflecting on the observed challenges to teaching neocartography tools.Keywords
This publication has 14 references indexed in Scilit:
- Data visualization: Science on the mapNature, 2015
- Common metrics for web-based mapping applications in academic librariesOnline Information Review, 2014
- Cartographic Interaction Primitives: Framework and SynthesisThe Cartographic Journal, 2012
- Is There a Need for Neo-Cartography?Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 2011
- Revisiting Web Cartography in the United States: the Rise of User-Centered DesignCartography and Geographic Information Science, 2011
- User-friendly web mapping: lessons from a citizen science websiteInternational Journal of Geographical Information Science, 2010
- Map mashups, Web 2.0 and the GIS revolutionAnnals of GIS, 2010
- Evaluating open source GIS for librariesLibrary Hi Tech, 2010
- Web Mapping 2.0: The Neogeography of the GeoWebGeography Compass, 2008
- Usability Evaluation of Web Mapping SitesThe Cartographic Journal, 2008