Legal and ethical considerations around the use of existing illustrations to generate new illustrations in the anatomical sciences
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 10 February 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Anatomical Sciences Education
- Vol. 18 (3) , 289-300
Abstract
It is likely existing anatomical illustrations are often used as the basis for new illustrative works, given not all illustrators have access to human tissues, bodies, or prosections on which to base their illustrations. Potential issues arise with this practice in the realms of copyright infringement and plagiarism when authors are seeking to publish, a matter becoming more prevalent with the proliferation in publishing platforms and the increased adoption of generative artificial intelligence applications within academia. However, there is little published guidance that might inform authors when using an existing illustration as the basis for new work. This article provides information pertaining to copyright, copyright infringement, fair use and fair dealings, plagiarism, and the overlap of copyright and plagiarism to highlight issues of law and ethics that are relevant to the creation of illustrations. Interestingly, the determination of exactly what constitutes an “original” illustration per construction from a secondary source has not been determined in case law for anatomy illustrations. This fact illuminates the absence of a “bright‐line” test for illustration reproduction and the difficulties in the objective assessment of what constitutes a “nonoriginal” illustration. The term “substantively different” is useful for determining whether illustrations derived from secondary sources can be deemed original. This article delivers guidance on how to develop illustrations with reference to determining whether copyright has been breached or plagiarism has occurred. It also provides information that will direct decision‐making around illustrative content.Keywords
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- Considerations on the use of artificial intelligence in generating anatomical images: Comment on “Evaluating AI‐powered text‐to‐image generators for anatomical illustration: A comparative study”Anatomical Sciences Education, 2023
- IFAA recommendations for the ethical use of anatomical imagesAnatomical Sciences Education, 2023
- Evaluating AI‐powered text‐to‐image generators for anatomical illustration: A comparative studyAnatomical Sciences Education, 2023
- Visual Plagiarism: Seeing the Forest and the Trees2022
- Plagiarism in Graphic Design2018
- Ethical issues surrounding the use of images from donated cadavers in the anatomical sciencesClinical Anatomy, 2015
- Growth rates of modern science: A bibliometric analysis based on the number of publications and cited referencesJournal of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2015
- An Academic Publisher’s Response to PlagiarismJournal of Business Ethics, 2011
- The pattern of the thoracic splanchnic nerves as they pass through the diaphragmClinical Anatomy, 2010
- MEDICAL ILLUSTRATIONJAMA, 1941